14
You're All Invited to Join Flavor of The Week in A Toast. Yes, even you. The S'more the merrier!
submitted over 2 years ago by ID10-TWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

 
As always, the purpose of this thread is to gather the community to explore a category of flavor and its many uses.
##⭐ This week's flavor is . . . Toasted Marshmallow

>>requested by OdieDoodah

Post your own recipes containing this week's Flavor of the Week, as the star or in a supporting role, with or without development notes. Talk about other people's recipes that use it. Share flavor notes. Compare and contrast different manufacturers' versions of the FOTW. Ask for help using a flavor in general or to achieve something specific, offer advice, brainstorm ideas, consider substitutions, suggest pairings... really anything at all as long as it's on topic. But most of all, remember to have FUN

 


 
###🎉 YOU COULD WIN A GREAT PRIZE!
It's easy - all you have to do is join the conversation for a chance to win! Everyone who posts a comment will be entered into a prize drawing. The winner will be chosen during the Noted Podcast this Monday at 10pm Eastern.
 
>>The winner will receive . . . >>###$20 worth of Toasted Marshmallow flavors
>>courtesy of the Village IDIOT 🤡

 

  • The winner may choose up to $20 worth of flavors from the Noted Collection on Bull City Flavors
  • Delivery limited to addresses that BCF ships to (US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Germany, Belgium, Switzerland, South Africa, and Bhutan)
     

We've added a bit of technology to assist our overworked Punmeister deal with a few popular requests. Several people want to participate in the discussion but not claim the prize. Others enjoy sweetening the pot and adding to the weekly prize. You can add one of the Special Code Words listed below to your message and your request will be auto-magically taken care of.

|Add This|To Make This Happen| |:---:|:---| |!!DontPickMe!!|Your name will be removed from the drawing| |!!PickMeToAdd20!!|If your name is picked, you'll add a $20 gift from Bull City| |!!Add20FromMe!!|Your name will be removed from the drawing and you'll add a $20 gift from Bull City|

>>If you add to the Prize, it will be YOUR responsibility to contact the winner and ensure that your portion of the prize is delivered in a timely manner.

Delivery of all prizes are the responsibility of the contributor. The author of this post will not be responsible for any prize other than the original $20 of FOTW flavors

 


 
###🔗 USEFUL LINKS GENERAL INFO
Marshmallow on Wikipedia | Flavor Facts - Marshmallow | Toasted Marshmallow Recipes on ATF
ON REDDIT
FOTW - Marshmallow | FOTW - Marshmallow 2
PODCASTS
Noted - Marshmallow | Noted - Marshmallow 2
ARCHIVES
FOTW Listing | FOTW/Noted Compendium | Flavor Facts
LAST WEEK
Malt - FOTW | Noted | 10% off at Bull City
 


 

🗓 COMING ATTRACTIONS

Here's a peek at what's on the schedule . . .

|DATE|FOTW|DATE|FOTW|DATE|FOTW| |---:|:---|---:|:---|---:|:---| |Oct04|🍂 Hilly Tobaccos|Feb07|⭐ NFFF 3|Jun13|🍓 Shisha Strawberry| |Oct11|🍓 Strawberry Bakery|Feb14|🍂 Cigar|Jun20|Candy Corn| |Oct18|Brulee|Feb21|Mandarin|Jun27|Shortbread| |Oct25|OFF|Feb28|🍓 Strawberry Jam|Jul04|Cotton Candy| |Nov01|Peach|Mar07|OFF|Jul11|OFF| |Nov08|Donut|Mar14|🍂 Red Tobacco|Jul18|🍓 Strawberry Banana| |Nov15|⭐ NFFF 2|Mar21|Chestnut|Jul25|Coffee Bakery| |Nov22|Roasted Nuts|Mar28|Waffle|Aug01|🍂 Tobacco Time| |Nov29|🍓 Chocolate Strawberry|Apr04|🍓 Sweet Strawberry |Aug08|⭐ NFFF 5| |Dec06|Avocado|Apr11|Cupcake|Aug15|OFF| |Dec13|OFF|Apr18|OFF|Aug22|🍓 Strawberry Kiwi| |Dec20|Toasted Almond|Apr25|🍂 States Tobacco (Virginia, Kentucky, Etc)|Aug29|Citrus Soda| |Dec27|⭐ FOTY 2021|May02|⭐ NFFF 4|Sep05|Energy Drink| |Jan03|Wintergreen|May09|🍓 Ripe Strawberry|Sep12|Frosting| |Jan10|Beer|May16|Watermelon|Sep19|🍓 Strawberry Custard| |Jan17|🍓 Strawberry Candy|May23|Taffy|Sep26|OFF| |Jan24|OFF|May30|OFF|Oct03|Peanut Butter| |Jan31|Spearmint|Jun06|Popcorn|Oct10|Rainbow|  
####Q: How do flavors get put on the schedule?
####A: Requests and suggestions from people like YOU!

If there's something you'd like to see, just post a request in this thread. You can request both a specific flavor profile and where it lands on the calendar.  


Comments
Sort
4 points
 
by feds-are-watchingover 2 years ago

CAP - Marshmallow 7%

CAP - Double Watermelon 6%

CAP - Sweet Strawberry 5%

​

Nice and simple, old school recipe. Great for MTL.

4 points
 
by NuttyNana1over 2 years ago

Might be good with omega chocolate!

3 points
 
by wheresandrewover 2 years ago

Not a bad idea. Got a bottle in yesterday. Been prepping for the damn hurricane but I'll be mixing tonight since I may not have power in a day or two.

3 points
 
by HarryWizover 2 years ago

Nothing like making toasting marshmallows over a camp fire especially on a fall day.

3 points
 
by OdieDoodahover 2 years agoThe Real MVP

Since there aren't very many Toasted Marshmallow flavors (DIYFS, TFA, FW, DF, OOO), should/could the "Smores" flavors be included?

!!DontPickMe!!

3 points
 
by ID10-Tover 2 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

Sure, why not?

3 points
 
by eyeMsam89over 2 years ago

Which ones are the smores? I maybe got flv

2 points
 
by OdieDoodahover 2 years agoThe Real MVP

FLV Smore
NF Smore
CHF Smores
MB Smore’s Marshmallow Brownies
WF Smores Cupcake

4 points
 
by ID10-Tover 2 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

You forgot FW Smores!

Pretty much just gets the graham and toasted part right. It’s like you toasted a graham cracker, and that’s almost all . There’s a touch of chocolate, and it’s sweeter than just a toasted graham cracker, but that’s not a big rich hunk of melty chocolate or gooey marshmallow. Seems like you could build a smore out of this, using this as the graham and toasted note, and adding more chocolate and some marshmallow.

FLV Smore

A little less than half is marshmallow. I get some chocolate that’s not too bad, some marshmallow that maybe tastes lightly toasty, but not really, and no graham cracker anywhere, other than in the mouthfeel, where it’s a little dry and gritty. The marshmallow is sweet and fluffy. The chocolate’s a little dark, like a really light dark chocolate, and gets darker in the finish. Seems like a good addition to something like a hot chocolate recipe, with some dairy and a much lighter chocolate. Or maybe if you combine FW Smore’s that’s just the toasty graham plus FLV that’s just the chocolate marshmallow, you can easily get a complete S’more.

3 points
 
by oMGLUover 2 years ago

I've never used marshmallow before. I think I need to change that!

2 points
 
by lyndas_vape_storyover 2 years ago

Toasted Marshmallow works well for texture, mouthfeel, sweetness, and of course flavor :)

2 points
 
by oMGLUover 2 years ago

How does it differ in taste from marshmallow?

1 points
 
by lyndas_vape_storyover 2 years ago

Most of the toasted marshmallows have a slight toasted taste. Burnt almost. They don’t have the fullness of a regular marshmallow. Think campfire marshmallows, but but lacking in the body department unfortunately.

1 points
 
by ID10-Tover 2 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

You won the flavors! Congratulations! You'll be using a marshmallow soon. PM me for details.

2 points
 
by oMGLUover 2 years ago

Awesome, thank you!

3 points
 
by billyzbearover 2 years ago

Toasted marshmallow. Wow not very many flavoring in that profile. I see Bull City put up WF Smores Cupcake this week. I picked this one up awhile back. I would say it's not really toasted. It's a nice chocolate, marshmallow with some cake. The cake reminded me of a brownie, it's in the body, then the chocolate with a marshmallow finish.

Thanks Noted crew for all you do.

3 points
 
by Bob_ohms2lowover 2 years ago

I actually don't think I have any toasted marshmallows. I'll watch the show, & see if there's any must haves.

0 points
 
by Dick_Fatkinsover 2 years ago

Toasted!

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.