38
You butter believe even those who aren’t big bakery mixers will find this Flavor of the Week at least margarinely interesting
submitted about 4 years ago by ID10-TWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

 
As always, the purpose of this thread is to gather the community to explore a category of flavor and its many uses.
##⭐ This week's flavor is . . . Butter

>>requested by Sugarchoc

Post your own recipes containing this week's Flavor of the Week, as the star or in a supporting role, with or without development notes. Talk about other people's recipes that use it. Share flavor notes. Compare and contrast different manufacturers' versions of the FOTW. Ask for help using a flavor in general or to achieve something specific, offer advice, brainstorm ideas, consider substitutions, suggest pairings... really anything at all as long as it's on topic. But most of all, remember to have FUN

 


 
###🎉 YOU COULD WIN A GREAT PRIZE!
It's easy - all you have to do is join the conversation for a chance to win! Everyone who posts a comment will be entered into a prize drawing. The winner will be chosen during the Noted Podcast this Monday at 10pm Eastern.
 
>>The winner will receive . . . >>###$20 worth of Butter flavors
>>courtesy of the Village IDIOT 🤡

 

  • The winner may choose up to $20 worth of flavors from the Noted Collection on Bull City Flavors
  • Delivery limited to addresses that BCF ships to (US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Germany, Belgium, Switzerland, South Africa, and Bhutan)
     

 
###🔗 USEFUL LINKS GENERAL INFORMATION
Butter on Wikipedia | Flavor Facts - Butter | Butter Recipes on ATF
FLAVOR OF THE WEEK
Butter & Whipped Cream
NOTED PODCASTS
Butter & Whipped Cream
INFORMATION ARCHIVES
FOTW Listing | FOTW/Noted Spreadsheet | Flavor Facts
LAST WEEK
Grapefruit - FOTW | Noted | 10% off at Bull City
 


 

🗓 COMING ATTRACTIONS

Here's a peek at what's on the schedule . . .

|DATE|FOTW|DATE|FOTW|DATE|FOTW| |---:|:---|---:|:---|---:|:---| |Aug17|Apricot|Dec21|Herbs|Apr26|Just Blueberry | |Aug24|🍂 5's and 7's|Dec28|⭐ FOTY 2021|May03|Plain Lemonade | |Aug31|⭐ FOTQ VI|Jan04|Huckleberry|May10|Corn| |Sep07|Kiwi|Jan11|Pretzel|May17|Pineapple| |Sep14|Cucumber|Jan18|Banana Nut Bread|May24|Fruity Custard| |Sep21|Black Licorice|Jan25|Sesame |May31|⭐ FOTQ IX| |Sep28|Passionfruit|Feb01|Toffee|Jun07|🍂 Black Tobacco| |Oct05|Purple Grape|Feb08|Wild Cherry|Jun14|Plain Custard| |Oct12|Cactus|Feb15|Blueberry + Bakery|Jun21|🍓 Strawberry & Cream| |Oct19|SOUR|Feb22|Blueberry Candy|Jun28|Vanilla Custard| |Oct26|Dark Chocolate|Mar01|⭐ FOTQ VIII|Jul05|Jackfruit| |Nov02|Maple|Mar08|🍂 Gold Tobacco|Jul12|Rice| |Nov09|Smoothie|Mar15|🍓 Strawberry Lemonade|Jul19|Cinnamon Danish| |Nov16|French Vanilla|Mar22|Blueberry Jam|Jul26|🍓 Strawberry Milk| |Nov23|Apple+Bakery|Mar29|Bilberry|Aug02|Bakery Custard| |Nov30|⭐ FOTQ VII|Apr05|Pink Lemonade|Aug09|Toasted Marshmallow| |Dec07|🍂 ORIENTAL|Apr12|Clove|Aug16|Cinnamon Roll| |Dec14|Cocoa|Apr19|Blueberry Blends|Aug23|Malt|  
####Q: How do flavors get put on the schedule?
####A: Requests and suggestions from people like YOU!

If there's something you'd like to see, just post a request in this thread. You can request both a specific flavor profile and where it lands on the calendar.  


Comments
Sort
8 points
 
by wolfwheelerabout 4 years ago

I want to formally petition that if someone requests an episode that is sure to be full of terrible flavors, that person who requested it has to be on that episode.

6 points
 
by ID10-Tabout 4 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

I’ll sign!

1 points
 
by SaschaAlexandraabout 4 years agoMissing One Flavor

Are you sad to be doing butter?

2 points
 
by wolfwheelerabout 4 years ago

They are not all bad.

1 points
 
by SaschaAlexandraabout 4 years agoMissing One Flavor

Agreed, and the good ones make it a worthwhile week.

5 points
 
by kuri_sanTouabout 4 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

CAP Golden Butter for me. Hoping to hear more about VT Butter Base though

2 points
 
by apocalypticdiynewbabout 4 years ago

How does Cap Golden butter compare to Tfa butter? Wondering if it would be worth picking up some Cap.

3 points
 
by kuri_sanTouabout 4 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

Do you have TFA? I was told CAP was like clarified butter but I don’t even know what that is in real life. I mean I googled what it was, I just never made it

3 points
 
by apocalypticdiynewbabout 4 years ago

Yes I have Tfa, it's pretty much melted butter. Clarified butter is pure butterfat. Basically butter minus the milk solids and water content.

2 points
 
by hesheretteabout 4 years agoMissing One Flavor

Clarified butter is also called Ghee, if you've ever heard of that Kuri! it's delicious fatty goodness (basically pure butterfat; they "clarify" the butter by removing the milk solids + water). it's huge in the Keto/ Paleo diet communities.

EDIT: (I just realized someone else already explained this to you, lol my apologies for not reading more before posting)

4 points
 
by theunmanifestedabout 4 years ago

Just ordered some FA Butter, but my fav so far is TFA Butter. Thanks to the Noted crew, and I do want to win that giveaway, so.... here's a poem about butter: https://poets.org/poem/butter

4 points
 
by ClubDazzlingabout 4 years ago

I butter think of a joke

3 points
 
by apocalypticdiynewbabout 4 years ago

I have only used Tfa butter. Definitely interested if any more are worth picking up.

3 points
 
by isuamadogabout 4 years agoRenaissance Mixer

Vt croissant usually brings enough butter that I never used my butter flavors.

3 points
 
by RumPirate613about 4 years agoMissing One Flavor

I know you’re against movie theater butter u/ID10-T but I like it.

1 points
 
by wheresandrewabout 4 years ago

Who makes a movie theater butter flavor?

3 points
 
by DutchSavage73about 4 years ago

Wayne sez he would love to have his DIYORDIE One Shots critically reviewed (on MIDWEEK CRITIQUE this week). I think NOTED should add a top One Shots review week. That would be....fun :)

2 points
 
by Mat_outdoorsabout 4 years ago

Please tell me you didn’t miss the opportunity to have Folkart guest this one?

2 points
 
by the_ohmie_bambinoabout 4 years ago

Everythings better with a lil butter

1 points
 
by MyIilbitabout 4 years ago

Especially popcorn…. Wait don’t know how that would vape 😱

2 points
 
by Steve-TCabout 4 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2021 - Melon Glazed Donut

Is FW Vanilla butternut also something to be reviewed under butter? 😉

You know I always try to stretch the episode 🤪

4 points
 
by OdieDoodahabout 4 years agoThe Real MVP

I think you deserve a pat on the back for sticking up for the poor neglected squash. All it takes is a little buttering up and /u/ID10-T will do anything - so keep trying!
 
(smirk)

2 points
 
by ID10-Tabout 4 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

That would be quite a stretch

2 points
 
by MongooseUpbeat1163about 4 years ago

I agree, CAP Golden Butter is almost linear in a mix(if that makes sense)...maybe w/AP in a granola mix there's a place for it, maybe. But, still, there's definitely better options. TFA Butter is butter...I haven't tried/tested VT Butter Base, I have it. I'm very much lookin' forward to this Noted...as much as any other really. Noted is pretty much my life-line for flavor description content lol Makes me feel lazy af for not SFT'n. Noted crew absolute maniacs wit' the sft's...ty ty ty For that & so much more. You guys/gals ROCK

2 points
 
by jewdifulabout 4 years ago

Been ordering FA butter from Australia to the US because I’ve found exactly ONE vendor who will ship it to me. It’s truly magical stuff, I wish it was more widely available. I’m not at all worried about diacetyl 🤷🏼‍♀️

1 points
 
by apathymillerabout 4 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Chefs has it under their flavor creative line

2 points
 
by ReaperNullabout 4 years ago

My only butter flavor experience is using TPA Butter as an accent in a waffle recipe. It works.

2 points
 
by billyzbearabout 4 years ago

I don't really like butter. I should say I've always had a problem with my tummy and butter. As I've gotten older it has gotten worse. After I had my gallbladder removed I seriously have to take it easy on fatty foods.

As you can guess I'm not into butter flavorings. I did try WF buttercream frosting and I have to say I like it.

Thanks Noted crew for all you do.

2 points
 
by hesheretteabout 4 years agoMissing One Flavor

when I started DIY, I never really thought I'd use/ like a butter flavoring, but I bought CAP Butter (before it was Golden) in my first order bc it was on sale. Glad I did bc it turns out that butter flavors are must haves in my stash.

CAP Golden Butter is a pretty good light Ghee/ Irish Butter taste + was my go to starting out, it gives great creamy/ thicker mouthfeel without overpowering butter taste. It was a staple in my stash until I found FA Butter, which I find similar but superior to CAP Golden Butter. FA Butter is a Euro exclusive flavor (buy it under "Flavour Creative" brand on Chef's).

I've only used TFA Butter in recipes, gives a faint melted unsalted butter taste to me. Kinda seems to just fill out bakeries, custards, heavy creams. I've heard it's mostly just A/AP, which some people hate (I am not one of those people).

However VT Butter Base is definitely my favorite, I recently finished up my 10ml VT Butter Base + am going to rebuy it in 30ml. it's so incredible.

2 points
 
by ID10-Tabout 4 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

Thank you for sharing this. I haven't tried Butter Base yet and am looking forward to trying it out.

2 points
 
by AppleSauce710about 4 years ago

I only have TFA butter, Usually add it to cookie and custard recipe's. Looking forward to hearing about FA butter.

2 points
 
by burke5227about 4 years ago

I like butter. I like butter flavor. I like TPA Butter and CAP Golden Butter and one other butter I have that's kind of like CAP from a major flavor company. I can't remember what it is because it wasn't that great. But butter is not butter without diketones. So I ordered FA Butter.

Chef's sent it to me since in in the US. FA Butter makes everything thicker, smoother, and more rich than I can even explain. It's magical and everyone should use it.

But using sparingly. Like one or two drops per 15ml kind of sparingly.

2 points
 
by Nanafabulousabout 4 years ago

You butter believe I want to win. Love you guys!

2 points
 
by JoelOl75about 4 years ago

Ahh Butter!!! Cinnamon French Toast V2 #827 

|Ingredient|%| |:-|:-| |Acetyl Pyrazine 5% (TPA)|0.20| |Butter (TPA)|0.85| |Cinnamon Sugar (SilverLine) (CAP)|1.50| |Joy (FA)|0.25| |Maple Syrup (FA)|0.85| |Sweetener (Sucralose) (FW)|1.00| |Warm Custard (VTA)|0.75| |Zeppola (FA)|1.25|

Flavor total: 6.65%

From the work on http://tjek.nu/r/CD0C continued.

Added:

Acetyl Pyrazine - to up the bread note

Butter - everything's better with butter

Maple Syrup - going for maple syrup on the toast not powdered

Removed:

FLV Rich Cinnamon - I don't think it's the right one (although excelent)

OoO Powdered Sugar - Goin' maple

Replaced: MB Legendary Custard for VTA Warm Custard

I tried this and it's great. I dropped the butter and maple a hair from 1% for better balance. This is full-flavored at low %

1 points
 
by apathymillerabout 4 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Thanks for the chanceguys

1 points
 
by Nanafabulousabout 4 years ago

Been waiting on this one!

1 points
 
by eyeMsam89about 4 years ago

Your puns Butter be good this week

1 points
 
by bbulichabout 4 years ago

guess this would be a good time to SFT FA butter....

2 points
 
by ID10-Tabout 4 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2019 - Counter Punch

You won the flavors! PM me for details.

And when you do, kindly remind me to order JF Cookie Butter?

1 points
 
by apathymillerabout 4 years agoOne of "The Damned"

DAAP!

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.