42
Recipe Review: Wintermint Cream by u/Foment_life
submitted over 4 years ago by SigmaLance

Wintermint Cream

A Recipe Review

Mixologist: u/Foment_life

Published: April 9, 2019

ATF Link: Wintermint Cream

Description: It’s a shamrock shake...except wintergreen

My Gear:

  • OBS Engine Nano
  • Single Core 3mm ID Triple Core Fused Clapton (28gx3/36g) 5 wraps @ 0.230 Ohms
  • Odin DNA 250C - TC Mode: 410°F @ 30W

Do you remember that neighbor that borrowed your 50’ extension cord last year and never brought it back? Yeah well, me either...but I will remember this mix this summer when that Florida sun is beating down on me one Sunday afternoon while barbecuing.

I needed a break from my doldrums of ADVs and decided I really wanted to swing to the other side of the spectrum for variety’s sake. So I chose mints and went looking for a handful of mixes. This is the first of them that I will be reviewing.

The mix:

  • TFA Bavarian Cream - 2.7%
  • INW Shisha Vanilla - 1%
  • TFA Vanilla Swirl - 2.7%
  • TFA Wintergreen - 2.7%
  • WS-23 - 2%
  • Steep time: 5 days

Ok so straight out of the gate I am not much of a cooling type of guy. It gets kind of funky and usually detracts from a mix for me. 2% WS-23?! Holy cow. But hey, right there in the description of the recipe it reassures me that the creams will take the cooling by the horns and tame it. Uh huh. Right.

So I am all in at this point to stay true to the recipe which has some super stars in it. TFA Vanilla Swirl and INW Shisha Vanilla are two of the best vanillas in the business hands down. Pairing them with TFA Bavarian Cream was an excellent choice which created a super creamy top of the line vanilla cream base to blend with the polar opposite TFA Wintergreen.

On the inhale I’m vibing with that WS-23 cooled wintergreen which is followed by an exhale of creamy vanilla goodness. I can’t express enough how extremely well this mix blends together. The sweet creaminess does indeed reign in that crazy WS-23 percentage to the point where I have to question if I actually used the full 2%. I now believe that using less of it would have derailed the entire flavor profile into something that is actually less enjoyable.

If you enjoy wintergreen and sweet creamy vanillas - and even if you don’t enjoy cooling like myself - mix yourself up a sample and give it a test drive. You’ll be back at the dealership in no time for another ride. I promise.

Comments
Sort
8 points
 
by Foment_lifeover 4 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2020 - Gruber Grape

Thanks for trying it!

I'm glad you enjoy it

2 points
 
by SigmaLanceover 4 years ago

Thank you for your contributions to the community!

7 points
 
by MsEmotions220over 4 years ago

I was chatting on Discord the other day. I mentioned a that I was going to be trying out Ws-23 for the first and that I wasn't feeling well. Everyone immediately recommended this recipe, and I trust the opinion of the mixers on Discord. So I've favorited this recipe and ordered the TFA Wintergreen - 2.7% and will definitely gives this a mix. Thank you for sharing!!

5 points
 
by ayce_kover 4 years ago

A Shamrock Shake, you say? Just in time for St. Patty's!

Thanks for the review, this is definitely going on my list

6 points
 
by SigmaLanceover 4 years ago

This is spot on an excellent mix for St Patty’s Day.

If the other mixes that I have waiting are anywhere near as good as this then It’s going to be good times ahead.

2 points
 
by hesheretteover 4 years ago

well u/Foment_Life did just win the 2020 Recipe of the Year contest, so his recipes are usually a risk worth taking! Excited to read about your other minty adventures, as I'm not much of a mint/ cooling vaper either, but I'm definitely going to mix this one up as I have all the flavors for once :)

EDIT: dammit, I have PUR WS-3 or TPA Koolada, aka the exact same thing just from diff brands lol. Must've thought I was buying WS-23.

3 points
 
by Foment_lifeover 4 years agoWinner: Best Recipe of 2020 - Gruber Grape

I actually really dislike mint except wintergreen, so this was sort of the only way it was ever gonna happen.

2 points
 
by SigmaLanceover 4 years ago

I tried Kolada once and couldn’t get through the tester that I made. It’s one of those flavors for me that gets weird even at low percentages. Typically I mix WS-23 and Polar Blast at a 1:1 ratio together with a total combined percentage <1%.

3 points
 
by BasicallyDesruptorover 4 years ago

Thanks for the review, going to mix this up as soon as im taking a new order! Can you please Copy + Paste this to ATF as well? Would be great to have a recent review there as well.

2 points
 
by kuri_sanTouover 4 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

Wintermint Cream

2 points
 
by BasicallyDesruptorover 4 years ago

Can’t see his review there?

1 points
 
by SigmaLanceover 4 years ago

I haven’t posted it there yet, but will be doing so since I am migrating everything over there slowly.

1 points
 
by kuri_sanTouover 4 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

Ah, I misread

2 points
 
by LilBearLuluover 4 years ago

This is my favorite recipe of all time, so it's nice to see it getting some love. As a mint fan I can't wait to see the other ones you like. Thanks

2 points
 
by HotSauceVillainover 4 years ago

Would this still recipe will work without the WS-23 or Koolada? I'm not a fan of cooling so I don't have either, but I do have the rest of it.

2 points
 
by SigmaLanceover 4 years ago

I would think it would work just fine without WS-23. I usually don’t use cooling very much, but always try to make the first batch of the recipe the way the author intended it. I have altered a lot of recipes afterwards though to better suit my palate.

I would not use koolada though. To me it’s a weird flavor that would alter the profile too much.

1 points
 
by HotSauceVillainover 4 years ago

Alright thanks! I'm the same way about recipes. If I had the WS-23 already I'd definitely give it a shot as it is, but I wanted to try this right away because it sounds amazing.

2 points
 
by SigmaLanceover 4 years ago

I haven’t tried to without the 23, but check it out and let us know!

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.