26
Mixer Showdown #4 - Newbie Booster!
submitted over 6 years ago by OdieDoodahThe Real MVP

Mixers Showdown #4 - Newbie Booster

The contest will begin tomorrow Sunday June 2nd at 4pm Eastern (GMT -5) Be sure to come join the fun on the DIY_eJuice Discord - The contest will take place in the Mixer Showdown channel. Come join us as two teams battle it out to create a new recipe in less than an hour! Join the discussion in the lobby as we take a look at the recipe development process and have a little fun while we do.


Contest Details
(all times eastern / GMT-5)

4:00pm
We will introduce the teams and our judge - state the rules of the contest - and announce the prize
4:05pm (approx)

  • Teams will go to their designated (and separate) channels
  • Once teams are ready, we reveal the INSPIRATION and the RULE
  • The INSPIRATION (a photo, song, quote, etc) will be the starting point for the recipes
  • The RULE is a requirement or a restriction teams must obey when they craft their recipe
  • Teams have approximately 40mins to complete the list of ingredients for their recipe
    4:45pm
  • Each team must have their finished list of ingredients posted as a reply to this message at this time
  • The teams have 10 mins to add a Name and a Description to their recipe
    4:55pm
  • The creative stage of the contest is complete and teams return to the lobby
  • We wrap up the show with final comments
    5:00pm til ???
  • The discussion continues into the night . . .

At this point, the judging phase of the contest begins.
Our Judge will award each recipe up to 25 points based on the following criteria . . .

|||| |---|---|---| |Taste|1-10pts|if it doesn't taste good, nothing else matters|
|Originality|1-5pts|is the recipes a remix of a tried and tested idea? or something never seen before?|
|Accessibility|1-5pts|are the flavors readily available and used in many recipes? or something obscure that few people know about?|
|Inspiration|1-5pts|how well does the juice capture the INSPIRATION for the contest?|

Everyone is invited to mix the recipes and give their opinions via comments and/or UpVotes
Please vote for you favorite before 8pm Eastern on Tuesday June 4th
The judge's score will be combined and added to the number of UpVotes each recipe receives to determine the final score.
The team with the highest score wins!


The People Involved
 
Red Team
u/xGRANITEx - (aka Silky) Creator of Buttermilk Pie who taught AlfredPudding everything he knows ;)
u/eyemakepizza - You know him, you love him, you love to laugh at him :D
u/Jaximus_1 - British Newcomer and movie star (Goodnight Mr Tom)
 
Blue Team
u/AlfredPudding - Boy Wonder who is still technically a newbie - though you'd never know it
u/staybert - Octarine King and owner of a new alarm clock (grin)
u/Glasschalice468 - (aka RainbowDragon) Enthusiastic Rookie and maker of cookies!
 
Judges
u/Shyndo - still just putting liquid into bottles - and doing it well - take a look
u/ID10-T - the useful idiot that just can't say no (thankfully - grin)
 


The Details

INSPIRATION
Did you find a Golden Ticket?
Willy Wonka and the Snozzberry Wallpaper

RULE
Don't be as greedy as Veruca - you don't need that many!
You may not use any single flavor concentrate higher than 2%

PRIZE
The newest contestant on the winning team will receive a Newbie Booster Pack:

  • One free month on DIYorDie - courtesy of u/enyawreklaw
  • One free year on All the Flavors - courtesy of u/Queuetue
  • 10 x 10ml of Wonder Flavors SC of winner choice - courtesy of u/Vishousness

THE RESULTS
 
The winner is the BLUE TEAM
 

|BLUE|Taste|Originality|Accessibility|Inspiration|Total| |:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:| |ID10-T|10|5|4|4|23| |Shyndo|9|5|4|4|22|

Judges=45pt + UpVotes=5pts
GRAND TOTAL = 50pts
 

|RED|Taste|Originality|Accessibility|Inspiration|Total| |:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:| |ID10-T|9|2|5|2|18| |Shyndo|7|2|5|2|16|

Judges=34pt + UpVotes=3pts
GRAND TOTAL = 37 pts



If you'd like to compete in future showdowns, would be willing to judge, or contribute to the prize pool - please leave a message in the Mixer Showdown Lobby on Discord, reply to the General Comments section below, or contact OdieDoodah



If you missed the fun from previous Showdowns - you can see them here:
 

  • Mixers Showdown #1 - One of these things . . .
  • Mixers Showdown #2 - Big Rock Candy Mountain
  • Mixers Showdown #3 - Seuss Juice
     
    You can see how the teams developed their recipes in the RedTeam and BlueTeam channels on the DIY_eJuice Discord Server
    Use the pinned messages to jump to each contest
     
    The previous two Showdowns and this one have occurred at the same time and on the same day of the week. Do not expect this to continue. We'll be changing the day of the week and time to the day to accommodate others that want to join the fun but are unable to join in at that time.

Please do not reply directly to this message - ONLY reply to the "General Comments" or one of the Teams Recipes so that voting remains streamlined. Thank you.

Comments
Sort
9 points
 
by staybertover 6 years agoThe Soda Man

BLUE TEAM: Golden Snozzberry Custard

|Co.|Flavor|%| |:-|:-|:-| |INW|Yes, We Cheesecake|2| |CAP|Vanilla Custard|2| |FA|Meringue|1| |FLV|Milk & Honey|0.4| |INW|Cactus|0.75| |TPA|Strawberry Ripe|2| |JF|Sweet Strawberry|1| |FA|Fuji|0.5|

This is a rich and luxurious custard, crafted with the finest snozzberries in the world and drizzled with a sauce imported directly from the land of milk and honey. We'll pretend it's topped with some 24k gold flake just to really sell the theme.

5 points
 
by n0tveganover 6 years agoStill Believes in Coconut Extra

I already upvoted this the moment I tried it as SnV, but I tried it again now and I have to say! Bravo to you, this is my new favorite custard and I'm not the greatest friend of custards to begin with.

The cactus works so well in there too, another plus, I really have all the flavors needed for it, sadly I am missing one for the red teams recipe.

4 points
 
by ID10-Tover 6 years agoThe Kingmaker

#Blue Team

Taste: 10

Addictively delicious. It tastes like nothing I’ve ever tasted before, which makes it hard to describe. The cactus is identifiable, but mutated into something more like a prickly pear and less like a cactus paddle.It’s not soapy or floral or aloe-y or anything like that, it’s just fruity and natural yet unnatural at the same time, like something grown on another planet. It tastes like the green-yellow-red color of a mango if that color were a flavor, with some gently citrusy notes and a wet fruity bubblegum syrup body. All of that is situated, somehow, in a creamy silky custard, which, even without sweetener, has a sweet, sugary finish, like the alien making this custard did not skimp on the sugar or maybe forgot to brûlée a snozzberry crème brûlée. This is is the best tasting recipe I’ve tried so far this year. Mind boggling that it was created in half an hour.

Originality: 5

I would give more points in this category if I could. They went for and successfully created something that doesn’t exist, like minor gods speaking things into existence. Let there be ~~light~~ snozzberry custard, and there was ~~light~~ snozzberry custard. I’m dumbstruck by how this was accomplished. On paper, I thought it looked gross. Cactus and cheesecake? Cactus and Milk and Honey? Cactus and CAP Vanilla Custard, especially unsteeped Vanilla Custard? Yuck, yuck, and double yuck. Now I eat those words and I feel unqualified to speak competently about DIY juice recipe development in the face of this actually working.

Accessibility: 4

I thought about dropping one point to give the red team an advantage in this category. INW Yes We Cheesecake might be as available as anything else, but it has a stupid name and seems somewhat new, or at least relatively recently renowned. But then I checked the facts. It’s the third most popular cheesecake, behind TFA Graham Crust and CAP NY.

Edit: I had originally given full credit here. I couldn't take a point for the Cheesecake, but I missed the JF Sweet Stb when considering this. Of the biggest flavor resellers, two or three don't offer don't offer JF at all. -1

Inspiration: 4

They captured the level of weirdness essential to represent something Wonka-related. They created something that doesn’t exist. But, there’s no reason why this would need to be a custard when it seems like a candy would be closer to the source.

Total Score: 23

4 points
 
by [deleted]over 6 years ago

Taste: 9
This is simply delicious. The cactus is a stroke of brilliance I absolutely didn't expect to work. There is no real soapiness. The biggest surprise was how the milk and honey morphed everything into this dark mysterious silky rich indescribable treat. The only misstep for me was the strawberry ripe. I just feel it could be slightly more vivid and simply removing that would do it. I also think the real star here is the custard. I feel like you could just port this custard base into just about anything and have a winner. Taking the whole thing in at once is so complex you end up picking different things out each time.

Originality: 5
It's got cactus and milk n honey in here. What the fuck? And it works. What the fuck?

Accessibility: 4
Just The inw and jungle flavors holding this back here. I'd argue it's worth the purchase tho.

Inspiration: 4
Only taking one point off here because to me the real star of the show is the dark bridge they built with milk n honey. Not exactly the Snausberry itself. It's only out-shined because every moving part is so DAMN GOOD.

Worth a mix? Fuck yeah. You'd be an idiot to not give this a try if you have the flavors.

3 points
 
by eyemakepizzaover 6 years agoThe Ice Cream Man

#Stay Berried RainbowPudding

  • TFA Bavarian Cream 1%

  • FA Raspberry 1%

  • FLV Boysenberry 2%

  • INW Custard 1.5%

  • INW Shisha Strawberry 1.5%

  • FLV Vanilla Pudding .75%

The Golden Ticket to a proper Pudding. A thick blend of candied berries swirled into a velvety rich vanilla pudding. So good you'll lick the walls of the bowl clean!

2 points
 
by [deleted]over 6 years ago

Taste: 7
I think the base custard flavor is pretty solid. It's super thick with a slightly carmelized pudding finish. It's slightly nutty and muddled from the inw custard which is the only thing that holds it back from greatness. That's usually the trade-off with inw custard though and it seems like a calculated compromise. There's nothing off about the berry layer except the tiniest of green notes and in general the taste is something full. I think the use of flv boysenberry with inw custard is quite a clever stroke here, keeping it from being too dry.

Originality: 2
It's a generic fruit and custard. Nothing much to say here. At least add some interest factor or something to differentiate the berry layer.

Accessibility: 5
All common flavors and great tools used.

Inspiration: 2
I'd give this a 1.5 if possible as it wasn't completely ignored. In general it kind of phoned in the whole theme which is kind of lame considering this is such a cool excuse to do something wacky or whimsical and tell everyone who doesn't appreciate it that they just don't understand the mind of wonka.

Worth a mix? Absolutely, the flavor is pretty damn good. I'd say if you're in the mood for a good berry pudding this will be straight up your alley.

1 points
 
by ID10-Tover 6 years agoThe Kingmaker

#Red Team

Taste: 9

Red Team has indeed created a thick blend of candied berries in a velvety rich vanilla pudding, as promised. It’s hard to pick out the individual strawberry, raspberry, and boysenberry flavors; they blend together nicely into something like a mixed red berry syrup. Fruit dominates the recipe and isn’t terribly softened by the nice vanilla pudding, which is appropriately pudding-like and not too dry as INW Custard can be on its own. This is a perfectly effective and entirely competent use of all of these flavors and I’m not getting anything off from any of it.

Originality: 2

It’s a red berry and creamy custardy recipe. The mixed berry aspect is +1 from the minimum of one point they would have gotten for a strawberry & cream.

Accessibility: 5

I can’t think of a reason to take any points away on accessibility here. Does anyone not have these flavors? Why not?

Inspiration: 2

They didn’t ignore the inspiration, but there were some missed opportunities here for a more realistic take on the berries or some of the other fruits mentioned, or to go as dark, creepy, and weird as Wonka himself.

Total Score: 18

1 points
 
by OdieDoodahover 6 years agoThe Real MVP

General Comments

post your replies to either of the teams recipes or general comments here

6 points
 
by Glass_Memoriesover 6 years agoPalate of a Trash Panda

Both of the teams did great and both recipes look great. Wish I could try them and judge, but even still, it was an entertaining battle to watch.

1 points
 
by juthincover 6 years agoI improved Grack and all I got was this lousy flair

>Silky - Creator of Buttermilk Pie who taught AlfredPudding everything he knows ;)

Just to clarify, did he teach Al everything Al knows, or everything Silky knows? Kinda makes for smack for different teams based on that...

1 points
 
by xGRANITExover 6 years agoSilky

I've arguably taught him nothing.

He walks to his own beat.

1 points
 
by juthincover 6 years agoI improved Grack and all I got was this lousy flair

So, if you taught him everything he knows, and that is nothing.... Still dofferent than if you taught him everything you know (and still taught him nothing.)

0 points
 
by bl4ckn4pkinsover 6 years ago

Someone better post a flaming hot Cheeto in mtn dew code red recipe!!!

1 points
 
by Tamberina1over 6 years agoMixologist

Looking forward to participating in next Showdown.

-17 points
 
by rabidnzover 6 years agoElixir Sommelier

This is the most utter wank I have seen on this sub. This is the embarrassing side of vaping.

13 points
 
by bl4ckn4pkinsover 6 years ago

People are having fun. This is a creative activity. Don’t shit on people’s parades. Go back to your basement.

12 points
 
by eyemakepizzaover 6 years agoThe Ice Cream Man

eat shit you twat. Go back to your dumb ass WaxPen sub that no one gives a fuck about.

11 points
 
by Glass_Memoriesover 6 years agoPalate of a Trash Panda

You're the embarrassing side of humanity.

10 points
 
by OdieDoodahover 6 years agoThe Real MVP

Thank you for being a dick.

9 points
 
by UnappreciatedRobotover 6 years agoI have no idea what I'm doing

Hey! This guy doesn’t like the showdown! See? Nobody cares.

9 points
 
by Korlimannover 6 years agoThe Man with a Plan

This has to be one of the most embarassing comments I've ever seen on reddit.

3 points
 
by bl4ckn4pkinsover 6 years ago

Posts a couple minutes before it’s starts... obviously tuned in.

6 points
 
by Jaximus_1over 6 years ago

Feel free to go elsewhere

6 points
 
by Kittybit8over 6 years agoI found my thrill on ID10-T’s hill

Best part is, nobody know who the hell you are. So all your bile spewing means nothing. Think about a little. You. are. nobody.

5 points
 
by juthincover 6 years agoI improved Grack and all I got was this lousy flair

If you'd posted after the recipes were posted, your comment would make sense. But apparently you posted... Prematurely. Which is probably similar to other aspects of your life.

5 points
 
by n0tveganover 6 years agoStill Believes in Coconut Extra

Take a hit before commenting next time.

5 points
 
by EdibleMalfunctionover 6 years agoI found my thrill on Blueberry Hill

Your mum is an utter wank

4 points
 
by Rickster4321over 6 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

Shouldn't it be udder wank ? Involving you in a barn asking why this cow only has one teat and horns.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.