30
Key Lime Cookie, or [KLC]
submitted over 6 years ago by RockyHarlow

Key Lime Cookie, or [KLC]

|FLAVOR HOUSE|FLAVOR|PERCENTAGE| |:-|:-|:-| |CAP|Sugar Cookie|6%| |FA|Florida Key Lime|3%| |FA|Meringue|1.5%| |FW|Hazelnut|1%|

I know, i know. Another fucking cookie, but this one is good! Citrus, chew, frosting, it's all there and in only 4 ingredients. Give it a try and you'll see. ^(YOU'LL ALL SEE.)

This is a very mild and gentle touch on an awesome juice by Element E-Liquids, also called Key Lime Cookie. It sparked me to make my own KLC and this was born. I took a general approach of a more simple version and I think it turned out pretty okay.

I have used varying percentages of the cookie base and the lime to find a nice match and this was the best. Turning the cookie down made the lime too strong, and vice versa, but using less of either just didn't taste as good.

Our cookie base is a simple one, and I tend to use it for "plug and play" with apples, strawberries, and the like. 6% Cap Sugar Cookie is the main note here, turned up a little higher than normal to stand up to the very potent key lime elements to this mix. 1% FW Hazelnut adds a more grainy texture to the sugar cookie and a little more 'chew'. I reckon this could be accomplished with AP at around 0.25% but who doesn't like Hazelnut?

Our lime note is simple and strong. I have toyed with CAP Lemon Lime, FA Lime Tahity, and some others but I felt none of them quite fit the cookie base as well as FA Florida Key Lime. As a side note this flavor is bomb diggity and a must have if you're a citrus lover like myself. It stands out in a mix, especially at the 3% we utilize here. Nice, bright, and green in a good way.

Our final addition is FA Meringue at 1.5%. This is one of my all time favorites, and as I release more recipes you will see it pop up in almost any bakery, dessert type flavor that I mix. It adds a sweet baked note to the whole recipe and serves as our frosting/glaze element as well as an impromptu sweetener. To me it adds a faint note of crispiness to the frosting area of the cookie too, much like a day old corner brownie, again in a great way.

Skip the sweetener unless you have to have it, this is sugar laden and rich all on its own. I generally mix this at 80/20 but 70/30 seems to bring the bite of citrus out a bit more, so adjust to your liking here. I would suggest not dropping below 65% VG or the citrus of the lime combined with high PG will really bump up the throat hit.

If you do mix, please leave a review over on ATF. Thanks for reading.

​

EDIT: Steep for 3 days minimum. Four or five is better, but the recipe is forgiving if you want to crack in a little earlier. Any sooner than 3 days though and the Lime is a bit too pronounced and the meringue is waxy in a bad way. It coats my mouth in what feels like vegetable oil. It's pretty gross.

If you omit the meringue it can probably be an overnight steep, though the lime may be a bit throaty that soon.

Comments
Sort
3 points
 
by Vurveover 6 years agoVurve with the Swurve

This looks super fresh, simple, and great tasting. Saving it to try next time I mix.

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

I do hope you enjoy ❤

2 points
 
by KingGuardianover 6 years ago

In your listed recipe you have FA Meringue at 1.5%, but in your notes you put FA Meringue at 1%. I'm assuming the recipe list is correct and it's a typo in your notes?

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

That is correct. 1.5%. I'll fix that.

2 points
 
by Incendiroover 6 years ago

Sounds awesome! How Long do you recommend to steep

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

Three days minimum. If you can give it 5 or 6 it should be better, but honestly I crack it oped 72 hours after the shake almost every time. The FA Florida Key Lime fades less than other citrus that I have used but it will disappear if you wait a month or two.

2 points
 
by TheBorgerKingover 6 years ago

Element key lime cookie was one of the first premium juices I got to try but I don't get much cookie out of it at all.

I started making a recipe for it very similar to yours, but it's using TFA key lime. Didn't know that FA did one until now. Shall check that out soon! Otherwise, looks good but i can't imagine sugar cookie at 6%.

2 points
 
by LecherousLumberjackover 6 years agoI put on women's clothing and hang around in bars

> i can't imagine sugar cookie at 6%

​

Prepare to have your imagination ripped apart at the seams!

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

That is one of my favorite recipes to mix for people who say "I don't care, I just want something good."

1 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

I have heard a lot of good about TFA Key Lime, I may need to check that out one of these days.

​

I do understand your apprehension to push SC past 3 or 4 percent, but sugar cookie has that versatility to be pushed higher than you would imagine. 6% was the sweet spot for this particular recipe, any lower and the key lime overpowered the recipe to the point of being this citrus meringue horror. It honestly wasn't all that bad but ^(I don't want to talk about it). Of course if you don't like it that high, knock it down to maybe 4% and go from there. Experiment and let me know how it was if you do decide to try the FA Florida Key Lime.

2 points
 
by TheBorgerKingover 6 years ago

I will pick up some flavours very soon. Looking at making a couple of the great recipes from last year. Then I'll throw in some single flavours to mess around with.

I have 3, I think, simple SC recipes steeping (I have 30ml of v2 to get through). Admittedly that might be the problem right there, but they always seem so greasy. I have thrown AP in them to make it a bit more textured, but I think they're still a week or so off. Haven't even tested them yet.

1 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

The v2 of Sugar Cookie is definitely more greasy to me, and really not even the same flavor as v1. I think when I used it I needed a three week steep to even start to get good.

2 points
 
by azemusicover 6 years ago

Just made 30ml with 3% juicy lime (dont have FA) and FA Nut Mix (dont like Hazel) and despite first being skeptical about 6% Sugar Cookie thought it was too much, it’s really good!

1 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

Cheers! I'm glad you enjoy it friend.

2 points
 
by Up2myheadover 6 years ago

How does FA key lime compare to TFA?

I've only ever used tfa, and find it fairly dry and a little thin.

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

To be honest, I don't know.

I haven't used TFA Key Lime, though I have heard a great deal of positive feedback on it. FA Florida Key Lime is certainly potent, and I think the 3% in this mix is the highest I would be comfortable using it. It has that cloudy appearance like FA Lemon Sicily and LA Lemonade do, and an almost bitter bite to it initially. I have a raspberry lime that I make for a friend and it's almost sour when used with other fruits. A robust tang is how I would put it I suppose. In a bakery or dessert mix, the top notes are usually toned down by the other top notes, usually in a beneficial manner such as in my recipe above. To me it doesn't seem thin at all, and rather full bodied and juicy at 2%-3%. If you do opt to get it, I would try replacing it in a few of the mixes you already utilize it in to observe the difference between the two.

2 points
 
by Up2myheadover 6 years ago

Thanks for your thoughts! I'll have to pick some up. I love key lime, but only got a little of the tfa to play with, and ended up not really pursuing it more.

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

Awesome, I bet you'll like the FA a lot more than the TFA. Cheers!

2 points
 
by theBigGloomover 6 years ago

Ordered the missing ingredients today from BC. Will give this a shot later this week!

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

Heck yeah! Let me know how it turns out.

2 points
 
by theBigGloomover 6 years ago

Forgot to get back to you! I really enjoyed this mix and plan to keep it in my cookbook. Friends enjoyed it as well. Although I have to admit I was a bad boy and added 0.35% super sweet. Thanks for the recipe!

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

A little sweetener never hurt anyone. I'm glad you and your friends enjoyed!

2 points
 
by randyholmover 6 years ago

I mixed this up a couple weeks ago and just tried it today. Wow, this stuff is REALLY GOOD! The ingredients looked good enough to risk making a 60ml sample batch of it and I'm really glad that I did.

Thanks for sharing this recipe! It may become a new favorite for me.

2 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

Awesome! I'm really glad you enjoyed. That multi week steep really does wonders for the cookie melding with the hazelnut and meringue aspects. Cheers!

1 points
 
by captainmalexusover 6 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

Have you experimented with using RF lime (SC) for this mix?

1 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

I haven't, no.

1 points
 
by captainmalexusover 6 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

Have you ever tried it in a different mix? I'd like your opinion on it since you like citrus stuff

1 points
 
by RockyHarlowover 6 years ago

I have not used RF Lime at all as far as I can remember. I'm a little scared on most of RF's lineup.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.