12
Tart yet sweet, trying to bring out the best of both worlds.
submitted over 7 years ago by MY13FXT

Greetings fellow eJuice craft-masters.

I'm seeking some advice / help / suggestions / discussion about tartness and sweetness (creamy and fruity). I’m relatively new to DIY, and having interesting time getting that constant tart taste. While maintaining a sweet smell / afternotes.

Tart / Sweet (ADV) and Raspberry / Strawberry (ADV) this recipe I’ve been working on for a little while, and it’s very close to what I want to achieve.

I’ve been working a lot with Raspberry (TPA) and Raspberry (Sweet) (TPA). These two flavors are tricky because they smell horrible, but taste amazing (if done right ). I have found very little information regarding best use or end results about Raspberry (Sweet) (TPA), and even less about Raspberry (TPA). However, I know that these two have the tart properties I’m looking for.

I include Dragonfruit (TPA) to blend fruit together. While providing more tart to the mix. I have not worked much with dragon fruit, but have heard good things about its properties.

How I have achieved the sweet “creamy “afternotes, and smell is through Marshmallow (TPA). I believe this to be a secret weapon. When coupled with fruit. Marshmallow does an amazing job giving balance to tartness. Although, I’m still having trouble getting the right percentages.

I’m still experimenting with Strawberry (Ripe) (TPA) and Strawberry (TPA). I found either there is too much strawberry, or too little of either strawberry. I really enjoy the strawberries mixed together generally trying to achieve a 2:1 ratio. Although, I should possibly consider using just one or the other.

Basically, I am trying to achieve tart yet sweet, creamy yet fruity all in one.

Comments
Sort
5 points
 
by Bassmuttover 7 years ago

That can be a booger to get right. But you seem to be on the right track. I add raspberry for a tart note as well.
If you can get it Fa raspberry is decent for that. Though raspberry sweet is good as well.
A little lemon can help as well. Fa lemon Sicily or fe lemon if you can get it.
For sweetness , a ltitle sucralose could help. Tfa marshmallow is good for sweetening as well.
There is Tfa sweet and tart. A little bit can help out. But it mostly taste like a sweet tart.
Bout all I got.

2 points
 
by MY13FXTover 7 years ago

Thanks for the suggestions on flavors. I have FA Lemon Sicily on my next order sheet ( want to make some sort of lemonade ).

With TFA Raspberry ( sweet ) is there certain percentage or range that you prefer when mixing?

3 points
 
by skiddlzninjaover 7 years agoThat one moderator. You know, the honey guy.

1 drop INW rhubarb/30mL will make any juice sour or tart. It's an ungodly potent, yet accurate rhubarb flavor.

2 points
 
by Bassmuttover 7 years ago

1% or so for just some tartness , 3% or more for an actual raspberry note. I mix kind of low though.

1 points
 
by MY13FXTover 7 years ago

I've been mixing anywhere from 10% to my most recent 17% - that was one of the things I was thinking that might effect tartness. Becoming diluted.

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

FA Lemon Sicily is NOT a lemonade flavor. It's more like lemon zest or a Limoncello flavor, but it can turn a actual lemonade style lemon into old fashioned lemonade rather than commercial lemonade. INW Lemon Mix does much the same, but is a bit more potent.

2 points
 
by MY13FXTover 7 years ago

Regarding lemonade I was considering Lemon Sicily (FA), and Lemonade (Natural) (FW). I have not made anything of the sort so im not sure the direction I wanted to go. Although, this does give me something to think about.

1 points
 
by TheKameoover 7 years ago

I would experiment with a citrus flavor as well in order to balance out the sweet. A personal favorite concentrate of mine is the TPA Green Apple, but if you are going for a cream flavor a few drops of TPA Orange Cream might do the trick. The dragonfruit is a great go to pick for mixing a nice blend of fruits.

3 points
 
by wh1skeyk1ngover 7 years agoThanks for reading this flair

If you're looking for tart, INW Rhubarb is the ticket. Use sparingly though, try 0.2% or so to start because it's very potent.

1 points
 
by DreadPirateSnufflesover 7 years ago

INW Raspberry is easily one of the best, most authentic and tart raspberries I've ever had. I recently mixed up DIYorDIE's TKO clutch raspberry lemonade which uses it, and it's probably the most tart/sour mixes I've ever had

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

It's also prone to turning into cologne if used too heavily. And it's quite concentrated.

2 points
 
by DreadPirateSnufflesover 7 years ago

Yeah I have heard that.. but I haven't personally experienced it. I know it's most commonly used around 1% but the raspberry lemonade recipe used it at 2.5% and it worked excellently

2 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

And it actually tasted like raspberry rather than flowers? Are you sure it was the same one? IIRC there's the Malina and another one. One was normal INW and the other from their Wera Garden line.

2 points
 
by skiddlzninjaover 7 years agoThat one moderator. You know, the honey guy.

INW raspberry is one of the worst flavors I've had. Makes everything taste like a raspberry blowpop that was put in a puddle with the wrapper, then you sucked on only the wrapper.

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Are you channeling the future (as in next week) ghost of someone?

1 points
 
by MY13FXTover 7 years ago

Raspberry (INW) comparable to Raspberry / Raspberry (sweet) (TFA) ?

1 points
 
by DreadPirateSnufflesover 7 years ago

Uhmmm. I mean you could interchange them if you wanted, but in my experience Raspberry Sweet is much weaker, seems to have maltol, and it can get covered up in the mix much more easily. It is also more of a candied flavor, almost like a raspberry flavored candy like laffy Taffy. INW raspberry is more like freshly squeezed raspberry juice mixed with maybe raspberry syrup, the kind you'd put on snow cones or in Italian soda- just without the sugary sweetness. INW seems much more authentic. DIYorDIE does note that INW Raspberry can be quite polarizing, some people do get those heavy floral/perfume notes. But if you DONT get them, then you'll probably really like it. Everybody's pallet is different though. Also this is in regards to their standard Malina version, I can't speak on their Wera Garden line

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

INW Raspberry turns into cologne when used at or above 1%. TFA raspberry sweet turns into Heinz ketchup when used around 5% or so.

Totally different flavors. INW can add some realistic flavor to the TFA if they're used together, but they do completely different things.

1 points
 
by rubermnkeyover 7 years ago

huckleberry works well in tart sweet scenarios as well. marshmellow is usually ethyl maltol it might cut too much of the tartness, you might want to try an alternative sweetener as well, sucralose or something like a pear might help sweeten it up.

1 points
 
by MY13FXTover 7 years ago

Is there a source that states clearly what's inside of artificial sweeteners / flavours? Labeling on the bottles is very basic. At this point I've used very little methodology when mixing. Mostly just brute force trial and error. While reading reviews / comments about a specific flavours.

1 points
 
by rubermnkeyover 7 years ago

Not sure, I know they get away with a lot claiming trade secrets. check here for a breakdown, might give you a better idea of what to look for. ELR generally has some pretty decent info in the flavor comments.

1 points
 
by MY13FXTover 7 years ago

I'll have to check this out. I can't remember where I found the link to SAFETY DATA SHEET Raspberry (Sweet) Flavor. While it does not give specifics. I found it slightly informative in generalities.

1 points
 
by loudstarfishover 7 years ago

FA Fuji apple in low percentages (.25% or less) will bring out a bit of tartness in otherwise flat fruit flavours. It's extremely versatile.

1 points
 
by MasterBeernutsover 7 years ago

CAP Double Apple or Green Apple works

1 points
 
by MY13FXTover 7 years ago

I was considering an apple on my last flavor order, but instead picked up Forest Fruit (FA). I have not worked much with it.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.