21
Anything as good as INW Black for Pipe?
submitted over 7 years ago by HankNice

So I've recently taken the plunge into tobaccos and I've picked up the following:

FA Soho FA Glory

FLV Kentucky Blend FLV Red Burley FLV Tatanka

INW Am4A INW Gold Ducat INW 555 Gold INW Dark for Pipe INW Black for Pipe INW Black Cherry for Pipe INW Vanilla for Pipe

Inawera comes out on top, but I didn't really like Black Cherry for Pipe and Vanilla for Pipe. Kentucky Blend and Red Burley are good but they are serious coil gunkers. The FA on my list are so-so.

Black for Pipe is amazing and I feel like putting it in everything! Any recommendations for must have flavors that I'm missing?

Comments
Sort
5 points
 
by ChemicalBurnVictimover 7 years agoresident tobacco expert

That’s like asking if anyone is as good as Jesus.

But for real, I’d grab some INW Dirty Neutral Base and try out some of their Tobacco Absolutes. The tobacco absolute Cuban Cigar goes really well with Black for Pipe. A little DNB in there and you’ve got my ADV for the past few months.

How high are you using the FLV? I can’t personally do too much FLV in one mix. I usually have one or two in a mix with some INW or HS tobaccos, and I usually keep them lower than 1.5%.

2 points
 
by throwawayeg3over 7 years ago

I'm kinda vaped out on FLV Cured / Burley / Tatanka. I'm not feeling the rustic tones that much anymore. Kinda hard to explain. Just put an order in for some B4P. I'm sold on INWs and StixxMixx Perique/Turkish Oriental for the time being. I bit the bullet and placed an order on Naturally-extracted-tobaccos for some premixed favorites with high reviews.

1 points
 
by ChemicalBurnVictimover 7 years agoresident tobacco expert

I haven’t tried any of the Stixx Mixx. I’ve done my own extractions with Perique and Turkish though. I don’t even think I’ve tested my Perique yet. NETs start getting weird for me after about a half day of heavy vaping on them. Probably the coil gunk. I’ve got an Aged Burley that is really good though. Even mixed at like 3% it’s super strong, so I want to try it at 1% and see if the taste to gunk ratio makes it worth it.

1 points
 
by throwawayeg3over 7 years ago

Might have to Paypal you some $$$ for that Aged Burley. Perique is solid and currently my favorite NET. I wish SM Aged Burley was stronger. One of my older recipes used Perique, Black for Pipe, and Oak Wood. That's still one of my favorites. I had to lower the NET Perique down to 4% because of coil gunk.

1 points
 
by HankNiceover 7 years ago

Thanks for the suggestions, I'll definitely check out the Absolutes.

And by the way, I like using Red Burley at 0.25% and Kentucky Blend at 0.5% together in a mix.

1 points
 
by jaydedrag0nover 7 years ago

Could I possibly get the actual recipe for what you mentioned? Please and thank you :-)

2 points
 
by ChemicalBurnVictimover 7 years agoresident tobacco expert

Sure thing! Brigade 2506

5 points
 
by kindgroundover 7 years ago

Inawera Gold Ducat, but I fear that they've reformulated it. It was on the list...

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

He has that one. As do I. (Hopefully I got old stock from before reformulation.)

2 points
 
by kindgroundover 7 years ago

My old eyes missed it right there in the middle! I have a bunch of old stock. More than I'll ever use probably.

1 points
 
by DreadPirateSnufflesabout 7 years ago

How would we be able to identify if we have the old or newer version?

1 points
 
by juthincabout 7 years agoमैंगो कस्टर्ड

SFT is pretty much the only answer.

2 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

What, no Hangsen?

And you should get a small bottle of Perique Black. Just in case you ever figure out a way to use it.

3 points
 
by ChevelloKDover 7 years agoProud Sidebar Reader!

Or for if you need green pepper for a salad or pizza juice. ;) That stuff is weird

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

I think in really really really small quantities it should be useful.

Maybe it's the tobacco version of TFA's Death by Cinnamon? I'll have to prep a 5% solution of it to test @1%.

2 points
 
by ChevelloKDover 7 years agoProud Sidebar Reader!

Maybe, just don't try single flavor testing it at 3% wow

1 points
 
by throwawayeg3over 7 years ago

Love me some HS Highway and Turkish.

1 points
 
by henrywinklersayehhhover 7 years ago

I've been into my rendition of Space Jam's Eclipse, but finding it somewhat too sweet. Not many people are into the tobacco Vapes... Could you help point me in a mix that's a good 'bacco vape?

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Cardinal? Or just search for recipes from /u/chemicalburnvictim

1 points
 
by captain_insanenoover 7 years ago

INW Cappuccino Tobacco (excellent to go with coffee) & RY4 (Any brand)
A new company called ProFlavor got a lot of tobacco concentrates as well.

1 points
 
by NotTheKyrosover 7 years ago

Where do you get your INW Cappuccino Tobacco from? My usual place doesn't seem to carry it.

1 points
 
by captain_insanenoover 7 years ago

Ordered it online =)

1 points
 
by dresdensrodover 7 years ago

Here are some suggestions to work with what you have

  • TFA Caramel Candy
  • FA Jamaican Rum
  • Acetyl Pyrazine for Nuttines
  • TFA Double Chocolate Clear
  • MTS Vape Wizard

Other Tobaccos I've enjoyed

  • FA Virginia
  • FA Desert Ship
  • TPA RY4 Double

I don't go super deep into tobacco blends myself but I like them occasionally and make and taste them for others that enjoy them.

0 points
 
by AutoModeratorover 7 years ago

PLEASE check the sidebar to see if your post meets our posting criteria. Delete your post and move to appropriate thread if necessary. There's a questions thread stickied at the top of our sub homepage for any simple questions you might have.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.