55
Good God, Lemon! You're the Flavor of Week!
submitted over 7 years ago by ID10-TWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

As always, the purpose of this thread is to gather the community to explore a flavor and its many uses. And it's also to have FUN!

Post recipes containing this week's Flavor of the Week, as the star or in a supporting role, with or without development notes. Talk about other people's recipes that use it. Compare and contrast different manufacturers' versions of the FOTW. Ask for help using that flavor in general or to achieve something specific, offer advice, brainstorm ideas, consider substitutions, suggest pairings... really anything at all as long as it's on topic.

#This week's flavor is: LEMON

How did that get to be the FOTW?

It was requested!

If you're not interested in this FOTW, please take this opportunity and comment to request one that interests you (or send me a PM to do that).

Past FOTW posts can be found here

The NOTED podcasts, which are bascially video FOTWs, are listed on this sheet. maintained by /u/apexified

Next week's flavor will be: Caramel

The week after that will be: Lime

The week after that will be: Cereal

The week after that will be: Orange

The week after that will be: Cheesecake

The week after that will be: Coffee

The week after that will be: Graham Cracker/Pie Crust

The week after that will be: Coconut

The week after that will be: Cookie Dough & Cake Batter

The week after that will be: Custard

The week after that will be: Peach

The week after that will be: Red Raspberry

The week after that will be: Sweeteners

The week after that will be: Cinnamon Pastries

The week after that will be: Vanilla

The week after that will be: Cantaloupe

The week after that will be: Honeydew

The week after that will be: Watermelon

The week after that will be: Pecan

The week after that will be: Hard Liquor

The week after that will be: Pear

The week after that will be: Cranberry

The week after that will be: Mango

The week after that will be: Ginger

The week after that will be: Cream

The week after that will be: Honey

The week after that will be: Peanut Butter

The week after that will be: Ube/Taro/Yam

The week after that will be: Cookies & Biscuits

The week after that will be: Lemonade

Comments
Sort
12 points
 
by EdibleMalfunctionover 7 years ago

I’m enjoying this dead simple, yet satisfying mix right now.

  • FA Lemon Sicily @ 1 %

  • JF Juicy Lemon @ 1 %

  • TFA Bavarian Cream @ 1 %

  • TFA Vanilla Swirl @ 2 %

Satisfies those dirty Lemon thoughts I get sometimes.

4 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

I love the combination of Lemon and Vanilla!

2 points
 
by EdibleMalfunctionover 7 years ago

Oh yeah. Speaking of, forgot at the last minute I added 1 % of Holy Vanilla.

2 points
 
by PepperMyJabrillover 7 years ago

I made this with INW Shisha Vanilla @ (0.5%), and it’s great!

2 points
 
by roidieover 7 years ago

Is there nay flavor that doesn't work well with Vanilla?

-2 points
 
by juthincover 7 years ago

Pretty much every flavor I would use. I mean... ick. Vanilla? What a horrible thing to add to anything.

3 points
 
by PerennialPhilosopherover 7 years ago

That's looks tasty. What's with the .0? At first glance I missed the decimals and thought that you'd lost it.

3 points
 
by EdibleMalfunctionover 7 years ago

Haha I honestly don’t know. I fixed that.

2 points
 
by SpaghettiBollocknaseover 7 years ago

Is CAP Juicy Lemon a worthy replacement?

2 points
 
by Retinalover 7 years ago

Just made it up with cap and on the shake I'm gonna say yeah.

11 points
 
by PerennialPhilosopherover 7 years ago

Lemon cough drop

1% FA Lemon Sicily

1.5% INW eucalyptus with mint

Perfect shake and vape for those days when you can't taste anything or breathe.

2 points
 
by herpsderpsherpsderpover 7 years ago

Sounds interesting. Will make some when my menthol crystals arrive

2 points
 
by EdibleMalfunctionover 7 years ago

Don’t even need it.

3 points
 
by herpsderpsherpsderpover 7 years ago

Straight up 1% Lemon Sicily? I don't have any other cooling flavoring.

9 points
 
by agentdark45over 7 years ago

Now this is a thread I can sink my teeth into.

I've got nearly every lemon concentrate on the market but the elusive sharp candy "tang" that I'm after always seems to evade me and my lemons end up either A. "Soft"/"wet", B. Pledge/perfumey floor cleaner

When I say tang, if anyone has tried Cereal Fiend from TBD liquids or the lemon note in Looper you'll know what I mean.

Can the mix gods chime in here?

The closest I've achieved to the desired result has been a combo of Cap LMP v1 + Cap Lemon Lime + FE Lemon (although this last one has a bit of a bitter rind note I'm not keen on).

INW lemon is incredibly potent and a great lemon, but it's not the zippy candy/sherbet sweet lemon I'm after.

3 points
 
by Noshferatuover 7 years ago

A bit of FA Cold Pressed Lime sharpens up any lemon, and gives it some "zing". 0.5% is when I think the actual flavour of lime starts to come through, so I keep it under that. For the sherbety, bulldog chewing a wasp vibe, try some citric acid. I haven't used it in a long time so I can't give you figures, but it's a "dissolve in PG then mix with it" jobby.

1 points
 
by agentdark45over 7 years ago

That's interesting! I don't seem to have FA Cold Pressed Lime in my arsenal. Definitely going to have to pick it up.

3 points
 
by canuck_vaperover 7 years ago

Have you tried FE Lemon yet? I find this to be a nice lemon candy flavor.

1 points
 
by St1llFrankover 7 years ago

FE Lemon is delicious. I got it for some cereal recipes and really like it.

2 points
 
by juthincover 7 years ago

I'd try mixing INW Lemon Mix and maybe LA Lemonade with maybe .05% FA Bergamot and some sweetener. That sounds like it'd get into tangy lemon candy territory. Or maybe a Marzipan instead of actual sweetener.

Basically, don't count on one lemon flavor to do it all. Other flavors can modify it.

2 points
 
by BuryMeInSmokeover 7 years ago

How do you find INW Lemon? Better for fruity mixes or bakery stuff?

I've ended up with some but haven't had a chance to use it yet.

3 points
 
by MasterBeernutsover 7 years ago

INW Lemon is fantastic - rate it highly. The only con I have is that it does fade a little over time. I want to see how it pairs with FA Lemon Sicily, but i haven't got FA LS yet. It seems to go well in almost everything - bakeries, creams, lemonades etc. And the INW Lime is insane, so juicy and realistic.

1 points
 
by BuryMeInSmokeover 7 years ago

Nice, I'm about to start a simple lemon meringue pie, I'll have to give it a go with the INW lemon then.

1 points
 
by St1llFrankover 7 years ago

> When I say tang

This part made me think of Purilum Golden Pineapple. It tastes like tangy pineapple juice. I wonder if you could use a low percentage of a pineapple concentrate to get that tangy flavor you search for. I wish I could be of more help but, I am still a novice mixer.

5 points
 
by RinVapesover 7 years ago

Capella Juicy Lemon - tastes like lemon juice to me. tastes nice in beverages. 1-2% for me

Capella Lemon Sicily- this is one of my go to lemons for bakery. It's more subtle than other lemon variants. 1-2%

FE Lemon - this is probably my favorite lemon if you're looking for something w/ a punch. (lemonade, candy, etc) it's bright and in your face but not bitter IMO. 0.50-2%

CAP Lemon Meringue Pie - nice bakery lemon, very versatile in pie, crumble or other pastry recipes. the pie note isn't prominent IMO and it has a slight sweetness built in which is nice. key component in "Lemon tart" mixtures. 1-3%

LA Lemonade - tastes like a straight up Lemon head to me... I don't get lemonade from it but it's still nice. 3-5%

http://e-liquid-recipes.com/recipe/2086777/Lemon%20Basil%20Sherbet

http://e-liquid-recipes.com/recipe/1607361/Lemonade

3 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

Nice notes, thank you

5 points
 
by MineDoggerover 7 years agoMixologist

It's not a Lemon party without old Dick!

(I'll show myself out.)

3 points
 
by eyemakepizzaover 7 years ago

Man, that show was comedic gold.

4 points
 
by c5b4c91772c729fc7d0aover 7 years ago

On my never-ending quest to clone Poseidon's Punch i happened to try a lot of lemon-y flavours:

TPA Lemon - bitter, sour, lots of throat hit, move on, nothing to see here
FA Citrus Mix - similar sour as TPA Lemon, but less throat hit
FA Lemon Silicy - Nice lemon, fruity, not sour at all, the go-to lemon flavour
CAP Lemon Lime - Peel, but works pretty nice in Lemonade/Gatorade recipes, pairs nicely with FA Lemon Silicy and INW Eucalyptus
TPA Lemon Lime - Less peel, but more lime than lemon.
TPA Citrus Punch - More Lemonade than Lemon, there's a reason it has the Mt.Dew nickname

Some crazy but great recipes I liked in the past were Halloween Ghoul Aid and 7up (there used to be another version). LA Lemonade & CAP Lemon Lime really shine in Darkly Currant Lemonade, while FA Lemon Silicy goes really well in creams like in Dude... where's my lemons. Together, LA Lemonade and FA Lemon Silicy are amazing in the Best Damn Pink Lemonade.

To battle a cold, I usually go for:

  • INW Eucalyptus & Mint @ 1.5%
  • FW Pink Lemonade @ 2%
  • FA Lemon Silicy @ 3%
  • CAP Lemon Lime @ 3%
  • CAP Super Sweet @ 1.5%
  • TPA Koolada10 PG @ 1%

Yes that's strong, and yes, it helps.

That's what I have for lemon, don't get me started on tangerine, lime, lemonades and pineapples...

3 points
 
by juthincover 7 years ago

> get me started on tangerine, lime, lemonades

Wait... lemonades is TOTALLY on topic here. I do lots of lemonades... what have you got? (And do you know a good red grapefruit flavor to use in a lemonade? And which cranberry goes best in a lemonade? And which would do better in a lemonade mix - Orange Gin or Red Gin or OMGin?)

1 points
 
by c5b4c91772c729fc7d0aover 7 years ago

Technically, Lemonade is scheduled for FOTW in 30 weeks ;-P

My favorites in that category are LA Lemonade as a general purpose lemonade layer, TPA Citrus Punch and FW Ecto Cooler (without the layer that separates if you let it sit, i suspect that's what makes people cough in Poseidon's Punch) for Kool-aid-related "lemonades".

FW Pink Lemonade and CAP Pink Lemonade are two completely different flavours, FW being sweet, bitter and grapefruity (like the cloudy Gatorade?) and CAP much sweeter and almost reminiscent of TPA Dragonfruit (slightly)

2 points
 
by juthincover 7 years ago

> Technically, Lemonade is scheduled for FOTW in 30 weeks

So? Flavors repeat as FotW... Someone could technically request 'White Chocolate' as a FotW, but white chocolate would still be on topic for a 'Chocolate' FotW.

2 points
 
by tweetchi11over 7 years ago

Just want to add that if you use ELR, CAP Lemon Lime gravity is wrong. Learned that after mixing it with cheesecake.

2 points
 
by c5b4c91772c729fc7d0aover 7 years ago

Thanks for that /u/tweetchi11 ! ELR (as the MSDS linked there) lists it as 1.403 g/ml, which is ridiculously high for a lemon/fruity flavor. Capella's own EU SDS lists it as between 0.97 - 1, which is much more realistic. For once, assuming 1 seems to be close enough :)

3 points
 
by ChemicalBurnVictimover 7 years agoresident tobacco expert

Really only messed with lemon once. It was kind of a failed recipe that I was frantically trying to get done for /r/mixersclub when we did the abstract mixing thing. It was Lemon Meringue Pi(p)e. It probably could have been better if I went with a more dessert style of tobacco, but I have a nasty habit of trying fruits with more ashy authentic tobaccos. Maybe I’m just gross. Probably. Just for shits and giggles, Here was the last version I tried:

  • INW Biscuit- .5%
  • INW Custard- .5%
  • TFA Graham Cracker Clear- .75%
  • FA Meringue- .75%
  • FA Lemon Sicily- 1.75%
  • INW Black for Pipe- 1.5%
  • FLV Kentucky Blend- 1%
  • FLV Oriental Blend- 1.25%

Probably don’t mix this. I’ll have to look for the 10 ml when I get home and give it a try. But I am going to guess it still isn’t good.

3 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

You're a sick man. I wouldn't be adverse to trying some kind of lemon meringue tobacco. I'm vaping a mix with Kentucky Blend in it right this moment and can see that working, but the Black for Pipe and Oriental Blend are a bit scary. Maybe Vanilla for Pipe instead?

2 points
 
by ChemicalBurnVictimover 7 years agoresident tobacco expert

I believe I tried it out first with Tatanka and Cured, but I didn’t seem to save a batch for that one. That probably would have been a bit better, but I think Vanilla for Pipe and maybe something a bit sweeter like FE Captain would probably be best. My main problem with it was probably the lemon though. I don’t think I want to vape lemon.

You just wait until that cucumber melon tobacco :)

1 points
 
by mlNikonover 7 years ago

Of course you would ruin lemon meringue pie with some kind of tobacco lol.

1 points
 
by ChemicalBurnVictimover 7 years agoresident tobacco expert

More like I ruined a Tobacco with lemon meringue pie!

2 points
 
by Prometheus_unwoundover 7 years ago

This recipe made me fall in love with CAP Lemon Meringue Pie all over again-

https://alltheflavors.com/recipes/78488#lemon_crumble_cake_by_the_one_beard_vape_remixmonth_by_enyawreklaw

I’ve never had the juice it’s trying to clone, but it must be pretty tasty. I subbed LA key lime and CAP LMPV1, coz reasons.

2 points
 
by noahdblevinsover 7 years ago~D.I.Y. Samurai~

I will be trying that one. Thanks for pointing that out.

2 points
 
by _TheCredibleHulk_over 7 years ago

Sort of on topic:

Does anyone know of a sub for FE Lemon, or a place to buy it in the UK? I tend to try and get all of the flavours I need in one go, so I mainly use chefsflavours.co.uk but they don't seem to stock any FE flavours.

It's for this recipe, if that makes any difference.

Thanks :)

3 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

I don't know why Chef's has rebranded Flavor Express to Xpress Flavors but it's the same stuff. In fact, it's probably the exact same place the creator of that recipe got his.

https://www.chefsflavours.co.uk/xpress-flavour/5073-lemon.html

2 points
 
by _TheCredibleHulk_over 7 years ago

Oh nice, thanks! I did a Google search to try to confirm that very thing but came up short. Going to pick some up, and maybe sweet rice too, as I've heard it's good.

2 points
 
by KratCatover 7 years ago

Funny, i had quite a coincidence with 30 Rock and lemon. A friend of mine came over just after i had finished mixing your Real Lemonade recipe and as i built a new coil he asked if i wanted to watch 30 Rock. I said ive never seen it, so we watched it all night all while vaping your delicious lemon recipe. The two made for a great night, and what a great show too. Sorry i have nothing valuable about lemon to add, just a story haha. Your Real Lemonade recipe is still one of my favorites though.

2 points
 
by KratCatover 7 years ago

Actually, i just recently got Flavor Monks lemon concentrate but havent mixed it up yet. Ill do that tomorrow and share what i think. Anybody try it out yet?

2 points
 
by drumbtrover 7 years ago

I'm having trouble getting a good lemon flavor that won't completely fade over the course of a month. Preferably something like a lemonadey lemon. Anybody have opinions on a lemon that won't completely fade out? FA Lemon Sicily and LA Lemonade seem to fade a bit, LA not as bad, but I just want some others that can work for a long term solution.

2 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

FE Lemon & INW Lemon for non fading lemonade-y lemons, INW Lemon Mix for non fading lemon zesty

But if it’s non fading lemon you’re after, probably any lemon out there would be better than FA Lemon Sicily

2 points
 
by brabs2over 7 years ago

Can anybody point me toward a good tasting sherbet lemon recipe? I'm new to this and would love to make some but I've looked and I can't seem to find any recipes that are recommended. Thanks!!!

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years ago

Lemon Sherbet... haven't seen one, so would have to develop one. So first off its gonna need to be ice cold (because otherwise it's melted) so there's gotta be WS-23 and Koolada. And you need lemons, so INW Lemon with a bit of INW Lemon Mix to make it that bit more vibrant. A tiny bit of INW Cactus to juice it up a bit, a touch of MTS Wizard (or a marshmallow, maybe) to thicken it up and you should be there. It may take a few versions to get the balance right. That's normal.

1 points
 
by brabs2over 7 years ago

Thanks my friend I will definitely look in to your suggestions 👍

2 points
 
by OdieDoodahabout 7 years ago

|Flavor Facts - Lemon| |-------| |FOTW - Lemon 1| |Noted ep35 - Lemons| |Lemon Recipes on ATF| |Lemon Recipes on ELR|

.

| Flavor | Comapny | Review | ATF | ELR | |---|---|---|---|---| |Lemon|Flavor Express| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon|Flavorah|by ConcreteRiver| on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon|Flavormonks| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon|Inawera|by ConcreteRiver| on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon|Medicine Flower| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon|Real Flavors SC| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon|The Flavor Apprentice| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon II|The Flavor Apprentice| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Sicilian|Purilum|by mysticrosell| on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Sicily|Flavour Art|by Chrisdvr1| on ATF| on ELR| |Italian Lemon Sicily|Capella| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Juicy Lemon|Capella| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Juicy Lemon|Inawera| - - - | - - - | on ELR| |Lemon Juicy|Jungle Flavors|by CheebaSteeba| on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Lime|Capella|by Chrisdvr1| on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Lime|The Flavor Apprentice| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Lime II|The Flavor Apprentice| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Meringue Pie|Flavor West|by mysticrosell| on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Meringue Pie V1|Capella| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Meringue Pie V2|Capella| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Mix|Inawera|by Apossium| on ATF| on ELR| |Lemon Zest|Flavour Art| - - - | on ATF| on ELR| |Shisha Lemon|Inawera|by ConcreteRiver| on ATF| on ELR|

1 points
 
by ID10-Tabout 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

I'm tempted to create alt accounts so I can give this more upvotes.

1 points
 
by juthincover 7 years ago

Am I the only one who finds FA Lemon Sicily tastes like Lemon Pledge until it's steeped a day or so?

5 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

I find FA Lemon Sicily tastes until it has steeped for a day or so.

2 points
 
by Prometheus_unwoundover 7 years ago

If it’s anything like CAP Lemon Sicily, It’s loaded with EM.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.