37
January Monthly Clone Challenge
submitted over 7 years ago by ID10-TWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

Howdy Mixers! How many new year's resolutions have you already thrown out the window?

Here go again. Nevermind that I'm STILL working on one that came up because of the first Monthly Clone Challenge way back in March 2017.

/u/SlashaLo is the MVP of the December Challenge and will be contacted about a small token of appreciation.

The purpose behind this monthly clone challenge is to gather the community behind an effort to clone just one juice.

The subject of this month's challenge is Hex by Golden State Vapor, which was requested by /u/penatbater

Penatbater writes, "Description says sour watermelon gummy, but im tasting more gummy watermelon. The sour is very light (probably only a tiny amount of malic acid added after the general mix was made). Has that cloying mouthful so perhaps some marshmallow was added. Not really juicy or fresh watermelon, more candy watermelon. But doesn't have that blatant artificial watermelon flavor. Perhaps cap jelly candy was added, I see that common in candy mixes. The watermelon is the trickiest one imo, coz idk where to start due to sheer number of variants. Also, seems like a good amount of cap sweetener I think, since there's this overwhelming sweetness lingering on your mouth."

A reminder from the previous clone challenge posts: You are perfectly welcome to completely ignore the cloning aspect of this challenge and just consider the juice description as a prompt to create a recipe all your own with that profile. In this case, that would be Sour Gummy Watermelon.

Please respond with recipes for Hex by Golden State Vapor, ideas about how to start an attempt to clone that flavor, your own delicious sour gummy watermelon recipe, general thoughts about having a monthly clone challenge, hate mail, love letters, lewd artwork, dirty limericks, comments, questions, concerns, anything remotely on topic.

If anyone would like to replace the monthly clone challenge with some other monthly or weekly community involvement-oriented feature, let's hear it!

Thank you. Love you all.

Edit: Sorry penatbater!

Comments
Sort
8 points
 
by DarkJester89over 7 years ago

Watermelon (RF) @ 2%

Sour Watermelon Candy (WF) @ 4%

Sour Gummy Candy (SC) @ 2%

Marshmallow (Purilum) @ 1%

Optional - Super Sweet (CAP) .5-1.5%

Hex is a perfect replication of a sour watermelon gummy candy.

5 points
 
by thepatient23over 7 years agoFrugivore

Do you get a candy flavor out of rf watermelon?

3 points
 
by DarkJester89over 7 years ago

I picked a pure watermelon to separate from candy, so it's a distinct flavor, but the sour candy will blend it in well. Straight candy candy candy will make it taste odd (in my opinion)

3 points
 
by thepatient23over 7 years agoFrugivore

I'd have to agree with you on candies sometimes tasting odd.

3 points
 
by DarkJester89over 7 years ago

R/chewymidget review said this is the sweetest, sour patch kid watermelon he's had. I'd say it tastes like sweet watermelon though, and an excellent base for a watermelon candy https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.reddit.com/r/DIY_eJuice/comments/5zum53/rf_sc_watermelon/

3 points
 
by chewymidgetover 7 years agoThe Colonel

I think it would fit well for the type of profile it's going for. The other flavors in the mix would cut down on the sweetness a little and I found the flavor to be a great candy watermelon.

2 points
 
by thepatient23over 7 years agoFrugivore

Just asking because i had to compliment it with another watermelon like flv to make it brighter for a candy. Maybe that WF concentrate does the same.

1 points
 
by penatbaterover 7 years ago

Does it have to be purilum marshmallow? Currently the only store I see selling these is nicotine river. Idk if a fuller marshmallow flavor will work better than FA, at least according to this review https://www.reddit.com/r/DIY_eJuice/comments/5qz7m4/purilum_marshmallow/

1 points
 
by DarkJester89over 7 years ago

I'm sure you could!

6 points
 
by penatbaterover 7 years ago

awwww yea! :D I don't have a lot of watermelon to work with, and it sucks my order of hex isn't coming till the 3rd week of january. It's my favorite juice despite being super sweet. I found an 80/20 ejuice that's practically either only koolada or WS-23, so I add a few drops of it to my squonk bottle to dilute the sweetness while adding some deep cooling feeling.

I will admit I am a newbie to DIY, but this will be my white whale. Once I've gone through a number of recipes, gone over the basics, and have a better understanding of flavors, I will try my best to clone this damn delicious juice.

Also u/ID10-T it's penatbater, not pentabater :D Like... peanutbutter, but pronounced with a Filipino accent. (I have also been frequently called patbenatar on numerous occassion)

14 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

Sorry I messed up your username. I've corrected the post. Please don't hit me ^with ^your ^best ^shot

2 points
 
by Apexifiedover 7 years agoSuckling from the teats of Daenerys Targaryen

This makes me wonder how the clone challenges didn't end up with pun titles

3 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

Have you ever wondered if whether something is wrong with you because you know you should feel ashamed of yourself, and yet you just... don't?

1 points
 
by bumfightworldchampover 7 years ago

ha, you win ten internets sir, thats pretty funny

4 points
 
by Loonicorn420over 7 years agoDiketones, Schmiketones

I vaped some watermelon candy

and thought it was really dandy.

Without much more thought

than a Reddit bot

said LA Watermelon could be handy!

3 points
 
by dutchahover 7 years ago

Definitely keeping an eye on this. That profile is something I've kinda been looking for.

2 points
 
by SteepingTakesTimeover 7 years ago

In my experience, mixing TFA and FW candy watermelons in a 1:1 is a really good starting place. They both have their strengths and together make a much better flavor. If you want to add a bit of "realism" to the melon flavor, I suggest TFA Honeydew. It has a fantastic melon flavor and plays nicely with watermelon.

The gummy part is tough. I like CAP Jelly Candy. It has a nice body that sits somewhere between swedish fish and boring jelly beans. It doesn't stand on it's own though. It needs support. A little CAP Super Sweet and maybe a splash of citric or malic acid can help.

2 points
 
by dutchahover 7 years ago

Candy watermelon with a dash of honeydew sounds kinda like INW Watermelon when you describe it like that.

2 points
 
by SteepingTakesTimeover 7 years ago

I'll have to grab some. For some reason I don't have that in my arsenal.

2 points
 
by dutchahover 7 years ago

It's not Cactus god-tier but it's still pretty damn good.

2 points
 
by Prometheus_unwoundover 7 years ago

Flv wild melon might work in this- it’s definitely a melon jolly rancher, with a mute farinaceous note.

3 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

Farina is the only reason I didn't have to look up that word.

2 points
 
by treylekover 7 years ago

Really? All I taste is cantaloupe w that

2 points
 
by Prometheus_unwoundover 7 years ago

It’s probably closer to a cantaloupe flavor than any other melons. So a cantaloupe jolly rancher, I guess.

2 points
 
by penatbaterover 7 years ago

Ok so I got my hex from the mail, and was previously vaping chrsd1vr's watermelon jelly rancher. As I said the watermelon flavor is different, but the mouthfeel and sweetness was very similar. So I think there should be around

0.5% cap super sweet 2% cap jelly candy 1% fa marshmallow/meringue

not sure which one tho but i definitely taste a very light creaminess to the mouthfeel at the end. I'm gonna hedge my bets on marshmallow.

1 points
 
by ID10-Tover 7 years agoWinner of the 2nd DIYorDIE World Mixing Championship

So now all you have to do is try a couple dozen watermelons to ID the right one, and hope it's not a combination of watermelons because that'll make it harder to figure out

2 points
 
by penatbaterover 7 years ago

And fruits. There may be some lemon or raspberry in there, not sure. Haha

2 points
 
by KhaosHakomairosover 7 years ago

Hello! First time poster. Has anyone tried to make a clone of Fresh Squeeze by Element? Based on what I could taste, seems like a combination of orange, tangerine and mandarin all at once.

1 points
 
by Bassmuttover 7 years ago

Chrisdvr1's watermelon jelly rancher sounds like it could be a good start , never had hex but really like the jelly rancher recipe.

2 points
 
by penatbaterover 7 years ago

I've just made his watermelon jelly rancher. It's not really it. I mean, they're both watermelon jelly candy vapes, but, idk the watermelon is different. Perhaps hex used a variety of watermelon? Or sth else? And hex is... jelly-er. Idk how else to describe it. x.x

2 points
 
by Bassmuttover 7 years ago

Dunno could be. Does it taste like watermelon sour patch? Wonder flavors has a sour watermelon gummy flavor that's good stand alone. Wouldn't wanna think a company would use one flavor but you never know?

2 points
 
by penatbaterover 7 years ago

I'm just waiting and saving up some cash, and then im gonna buy all the watermelon flavorings my local supplier has, which is about 9, and then test them out individually. Wish me luck x.x

1 points
 
by PoopStainMcBaineover 7 years ago

La Watermelon 3%

Tfa Green Apple 4%

Fa Red Touch 3%

Fa Pear .5%

Tfa Marshmallow 1%

Tfa Sweetener 1%

I taste a Sour Patch Watermelons flavor from this one.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.