If you are going to use koolada to replicate that "cool" feeling of a milkshake, try .25-.50% instead.

Check out TFA Malted Milk plus TFA Cheesecake Graham Crust for that maltiness you associate with milkshake.

I use cheesecake graham crust, fresh cream and CAP VBIC. You definitely need milk and ice cream flavoring, and something to give it maltiness and body - cheesecake in my case, but try small amount of hazelnut or something like CAP Creamy Yogurt etc.

Would using marshmallow make sense?

Vienna Cream (FA) Works pretty well. That along with maybe Meringue.

Give this a shot, probably the creamiest milky vape I've vaped to date.

Brand | Flavour | % | ---- | ---- | --- | TFA | Malted milk | 1 TFA | VBIC | 8 TFA | Marshmallow | 3

Marshmallow for mouthfeel, vbic for creamy base notes and malted milk for extra creaminess, at 1% it doesn't add much malt but makes it incredibly milky, any more and I think it might be gross. I usually just vape it with 6% Strawberry ripe and it's pretty perfect. Can also add a minute amount of dragon fruit to mingle with the Strawberry .25 -.50

malted milk tfa 2%

vbic tfa 4%

add 1%whipped cream or cream fresh or sweet cream. some recipes on ELR call for vanilla cupcake @4%. french vanilla creme@2%

the choices are endless but if you search "milkshake" on elr and sort by the ratings tab it will give you a solid start of something that provenly[sp] works

2 days ago I did;

 

VBIC 3%  

Milk 2%  

Whipped Cream 2%  

Cream Fresh 1,5%   CGC 2% / Creamy Yogurt 3% / MTS Wizard 0.5%  

Can't say I liked any of them so far by the taste of going for a creamy Milkshake icecream taste. I also tried with French Vanilla instead of VBIC for the MTS Wizard one at 3%.

 

I will have a go at them again in a few days but I'm skeptical. Also adding Koolada isn't my thing at all as I think the coolness draws too much attention from the flavours so going to drop it all together.

 

So far I'm still liking VBIC 4%, Milk 2,5% and Whipped Cream 2% best. Though I'd REALLY want to check out Malted Milk at this point. I like how CGC added depth but should probably have gone with 1%.

 

I guess my quest continues to get that perfect 'true' Milkshake base.

I'd agree it is quite high but used in conjunction with Strawberry ripe it stops it becoming a floral mess after a couple weeks steep, it's delicious as a shake & vape but gets much creamier given a couple weeks to steep. If you don't use the Strawberry you could probably take it down to around 1.5% - 2.0%. Let me know if you give it a shot 👍

I've been using this for a couple months. It a true milkshake IMO.

(Flavor Base) Vanilla Milkshake (Gmix)

Ingredient|% :---|---: Cream Fresh (FA)|0.5 Cream Whipped (FA)|0.5 Liquid Stevia (Pyure)|0.3 Vanilla (MF)|0.8 Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (TPA)|2.5

Flavor total: 4.6%

Remember to rate it at e-liquid-recipes.com!

10.87% Cream Fresh (FA)

10.87% Cream Whipped (FA)

6.53% Pyure

17.4% Vanilla (MF)

54.33% Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (TPA)

To be mixed at: 4.6%

marshmallow seems to help with my strawberry milkshake, at around 2% rounds out a certain "edge" to the flavor and adds sweetness

If you have access to Hangsen creams, they're very good. Also, Whipped Cream already has the Triacetin you'd be wanting from the MTS, so I'd skip that. I haven't had anything turn out well with the MTS.