11
The most underrated recipe on e-liquid-recipes.com?
submitted over 9 years ago by MaythamK

I'm sure there must be some gems buried deep below the thousands of recipes on there.

Comments
Sort
23 points
 
by rockofthedover 9 years agoI will rip you a new one if you don't use the sidebar & search.

would be great if we could sort that site by top recipe of the day/week/month/year etc... seriously lacking.

6 points
 
by MaythamKover 9 years ago

For sure, the top recipes have been the same for as long as I can remember.

2 points
 
by queuetueabout 9 years agoAllTheFlavors Creator/Admin

Although you were asking about ELR, All the Flavors now has this:

Popular and mixed is all time, "Hot" is the last 24 hours. I could also add weekly or monthly if people want it.

http://imgur.com/a/B8HQd

-1 points
 
by T_Maceover 9 years ago

Bump!

2 points
 
by CheebaSteebaover 9 years agoFrugivore

There definitely are some good ones on there. One of my favs that I stumbled on was Shaner's "Irish Thunder." Didn't knock my socks off or anything but gave me a recipe to try FA Jamaican Rum and made for a great ADV.

2 points
 
by coop34over 9 years ago

This is a great one. I have kept a 100ml bottle of this mixed ever since her original post. Because I still haven't picked up Cap Tangerine, I sub in FA Mandarin or FW Blood Orange.

2 points
 
by mangarooabout 9 years ago

Liking this one on day 2 already, I can imagine it coming out great. Thanks for posting.

2 points
 
by coop34about 9 years ago

Yep, /u/boneynicole created a winner with this one! I meant to add that a steep is not needed. Even tho it does change some, it starts delicious and stays pretty much the same for at least 4 months.

2 points
 
by BoneyNicoleabout 9 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Oh hey, my recipe! I need to mix this up again and see if I can tweak some things. I actually agree that there's a bit too much total flavoring - it's more than I normally use, so maybe that can be adjusted somewhat. It's been a month or two since I've made it, so I'll have to try it out again soon. I'm of course out of Orange Cream atm, and it's just not remotely the same without it.

3 points
 
by coop34about 9 years ago

Lol, I hope you dont mind that I linked it. FWIW I havent even tried trimming back anything, and dont plan on it. I have had plenty of time to do so, as this has been in my rotation longer than most, including my own mixes! It is so good!

And I agree that OC makes it what is. Thanks for sharing!

2 points
 
by BoneyNicoleabout 9 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Not in the least! I never use ELR and am just happy someone likes it! I just DIY because it's fun, so anything I can share that people like is awesome to me. 😊

1 points
 
by MaythamKover 9 years ago

I'd like to try that out, I'm missing FA custard, Meringue, & sweet tangerine. Do you think its still worth a shot?

2 points
 
by coop34over 9 years ago

Prob wouldn't missed the custard at all, and meringue makes it sweet of course, but prob could get by without it. Orange Cream is the biggie to have, so if you have that then give it a try! I'd like to know how you like it like that. I have always thought there was too much total flavoring, but it is so damn good I haven't tweaked it at all, except the one sub.

I really recommend FA Mandarin or FW Blood Orange if you do plan on adding an orange to your arsenal.

1 points
 
by MaythamKover 9 years ago

Got some flavours coming in on Tuesday so I'll give it a try then and report back to you.

2 points
 
by wh1skeyk1ngover 9 years ago

I came across Gentleman's Custard using the ""What Can I Make" feature recently, which looked pretty tasty. I added a couple things and tweaked some percentages to come up with my own variation, but it seems solid as is, and has excellent notes compared to the rest of ELR.

2 points
 
by ohm-societyabout 9 years agoMixologist

Thanks for the love.

I've recently adjusted that recipe to include butterscotch ripple. Once I'm done tinkering with the new version and happy with it, I'll be sure to make a post.

1 points
 
by wh1skeyk1ngabout 9 years ago

Well, hey. Since you inspired me to mix something along these lines, I'll share a bit of what I did. I left out the VCV1 and Brown Sugar. I threw in FA Torrone, FA Almond, FA Brandy, and TFA Kentucky Bourbon. Initially, I think I put too much Torrone in, but I tried it 2 days after mixing and the Torrone calmed down significantly. I can PM you the actual percentages some time if you're remotely interested. I've only tried it a couple times and don't have much for notes on it yet.

I've been looking to make something that isn't fruity, custardy, or cakey, so I feel like I'm on the verge of ordering a bunch of tobacco flavorings.

1 points
 
by Cstone19832over 9 years ago

I thought about starting a new site to compete with this one, I have some good ideas but lack the time/skill, I can do basic coding but not enough. Would take me forever to make it. :( if anyone wants to colaborate I would consider it.

4 points
 
by T_Maceover 9 years ago

Not to be a naysayer, competition is good, but I hope we don't see too many competitors cuz it will just end up splitting the community and watering down the amount of sharing that naturally happens when we're all on one site.

10 points
 
by eVapouratedAUover 9 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Not to be a naysayer either... But ELR is overpopulated with people who don't know when and how to mark their recipes as private. As a result it's pretty much become the twitter of eliquid recipes lol. Anything that's on anybodies mind is there for the world to see

2 points
 
by T_Maceover 9 years ago

I'm wondering how that would differ on any other site? Do you reckon that other recipe sites will be closely modded to prevent this? Seems like that would work until they reach mega popularity level and then it would be nearly impossible to enforce.

Edit: On ELR, search by rating. That is a user controlled self mod system basically and it works.

0 points
 
by Cstone19832over 9 years ago

I agree

2 points
 
by EdibleMalfunctionover 9 years ago

All-the-flavors is attempting to do this. It is on its way to being leagues better than ELR

1 points
 
by Ace81892over 9 years ago

This has been my ADV for a few weeks. Not sure if it counts as "underrated" as it has quite a high rating and a few comments. But it's not a big name that I've ever heard around here like Mustard Milk or Bronuts.

2 points
 
by MineDoggerover 9 years agoMixologist

6% Honeydew??? Oh, hell naw... You must have lost the mucous membranes in your airways in a work related gas explosion, bro... 2% will crush all your honeydew cravings for all eternity and stain your tank with its distinctive odor.

1 points
 
by Ace81892over 9 years ago

IDK man. I must be nuts then, because I really enjoy it.

1 points
 
by MineDoggerover 9 years agoMixologist

It's not a bad flavor, (on the contrary, its cloyingly authentic,) but I thought it got OP really quick. I had to rebuild and scrub the tank after a 4% mix because while most flavors will kind of "fade into" each other the Honeydew seemed just as strong after two tanks of other liquid... Just rolling right over any other flavoring... 6% would taste bad outright to me, 4% was vapable but that stuff is so potent I'd try a 2 or 3% mix (if you haven't already,) to see if it's still strong enough for you. If nothing else it would save on how much you're using in a batch.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.