14
Shaking vs Spinning new mixes
submitted over 9 years ago by Gregeddit

After reading several threads and watching some videos, I've gotten the impression that rigging up a device like this:

http://imgur.com/8QGWvgf

... would act more like a centrifuge and seperate the ingrideints at each end of the bottle.

But what if a similar device was used that offset 2 bottles at a 90 degrees like this:

http://imgur.com/pUKQ0pr

Would the 2nd method work as a DIY mixer, or am I missing some physics here?

Comments
Sort
6 points
 
by CosmoVerdeover 9 years ago

I don't know if it would separate things, but it probably wouldn't to much mixing if any.

1 points
 
by r3finiover 9 years ago

Naaaah... It doesn't separated and doesn't mix for long if any. I've tried it with a broken hand blender I tried to give a new purpose. The big problem is balancing the center of mass on the bottle you try to spin. Those rubber bands wont prevent them from flying over the room.

If you can spare an electric motor somehow and got some crafting going on; making a magnetic stirrer surface is pretty simple and worth it. I still need to figure out a nice way to heat it instead of periodically dunk the bottles back into hot water...

1 points
 
by Gregedditover 9 years ago

The rubber bands did the trick on a 15mL, but even on the fastest spin, no air bubbles were present in the mixture afterwards and I'm convinced that the solution separated more than mixed.

If I use a drill at all, the only way I think it would work is by spinning it on the same axis as the cap, causing the sides of the bottle to create drag on the internal liquid. Wouldn't aerate the mixture, but it would distribute the compound well enough.

I'll probably end up rigging a magnetic stirrer in the end, but I'm a tinkerer at heart and I'd like to see what I come up with ;)

3 points
 
by Nutz_of_Brinover 9 years ago

http://www.amazon.com/MixKwik-MT16-Tool/dp/B0055S7DJS

Bummer, for 12oz cans and up. :(

On the shitter google fail.

1 points
 
by ljab26over 9 years ago

I diy-made this. I'm sure there are a million ways to make this rig, just make sure step 1 is to cover the blade with tape or cover it with something for safety.

1 points
 
by Bass_Monsterover 9 years ago

Hell yes. I think I may need this!

2 points
 
by diyguy1over 9 years ago

I use a jigsaw. I replaced the blade with a small bar clamp. A 15 second shake is all it takes to get a really good mix, to a milky consistency.

This rig fits 15 & 30ml bottles quite well. The bar clamp was almost a perfect fit into the jigsaw, and just took a few strokes with a hand file to thin the bar down to fit into the jigsaw. http://i.imgur.com/OSrH3KJ.jpg

1 points
 
by Gregedditover 9 years ago

Oh wow man! That's a pretty genius setup :D

1 points
 
by druh07over 9 years ago

I use blender,then in a jar.then inside the lower part of the stove oven which is dark and in room temp.3 days even pastry tastes like magic

2 points
 
by Elab0r8over 9 years ago

I just use some 26/28 gauge kanthal, make it into a whisk type thing and shove it in a drill, bends enough to mix in whatever bottle and no separation problems. Works a treat

1 points
 
by Gregedditover 9 years ago

Oddly enough, I had the very same thought when my 26 gauge stainless spool arrived today! But I'm glad that I'm thinking along the same lines that others have had success with.

1 points
 
by Hydroxus_over 9 years agoI will rip you a new one if you don't use the sidebar & search.

If you want to rig something up use a reciprocal saw? and attach the bottle to the blade. The saw were the blade goes in and out.

3 points
 
by Clyde_Diedover 9 years agoFrugivore

I did this at work. Works fantastically. Shook so fast the bottle turned into a blur haha. I suggest taping the blade first, almost ripped a plastic bottle up.

2 points
 
by Gregedditover 9 years ago

Ah hah! I do have a jigsaw at work. Some stiff bungies and I should be in business :D

3 points
 
by BiggieSmallsEyeballover 9 years ago

Electric knives work great for this, too. Just use one blade, taped.

1 points
 
by ljab26over 9 years ago

Nice.

1 points
 
by Bass_Monsterover 9 years ago

I have one of these and I rigged it to mix juices. http://www.homedepot.com/p/Ryobi-ONE-18-Volt-Cordless-Reciprocating-Saw-Tool-Only-P514/100041044

You should replace the blade with something dull because the blade will cut through duct tape. And electrical tape. And a zip tie. The best I found was a pipe cleaner, twisted tight the metal gets in between the teeth and moves around less, so it lasts longer. Does a hell of a job!

2 points
 
by Binsky89over 9 years ago

I might take an angle grinder and remove the teeth on one of my blades.

1 points
 
by ruok5over 9 years ago

Say what? Angle grinders typically run in the neighborhood of 10,000 rpm...

1 points
 
by zdigglerover 9 years ago

Weld some hard metal on side of the blades. other wise they tend to flop all over.

1 points
 
by Nutz_of_Brinover 9 years ago

They're still spinning.

1 points
 
by ElGatoTheManCatover 9 years ago

I don't know. I just mix up my bottle, soak it in some warm water, and spin it in a tube sock for around 50 minutes. Works pretty well.

1 points
 
by VAPORMARKover 9 years agoProud Sidebar Reader!

I use a milk frother, then pour it into a bottle, then put it into my cargo pants pocket. My body warmth and normal movement do the trick. After a couple of days it goes on the shelf.

Larger batches get the magnetic stir and shelved.

1 points
 
by spokenthoughtover 9 years ago

How much of a difference does this make versus shaking by hand?

1 points
 
by Gregedditover 9 years ago

It doesn't introduce any air bubbles into the liquid, so I believe it's not really mixing the solution, just forcing the two halves to either end of the bottle =\ Working on a new drill based, sealed bottle mixer. Will update when I get something that works :)

1 points
 
by the-scotover 9 years ago

I use a Conair Foot Spa! The vibrations are perfect, on the warm setting for 12 to 24hrs and then, let it cures for the 3-4weeks. Every miX I have had done so far, has been at its greatest at the end of each batch but awesome after their spa treatment! Lo L

I am Just recently starting to make larger batches 220-500mL so that I have them at their best with a 4-6 week rest.

In regards to your Post, I too remember reading that the Juce turning End to End has the largest turn ratio unto its self. My Cuz tapes up his bottles and throws them in the laundry with a load on medium heat for an hour, he says the results are amazing for getting the Juce past those early stages of the mix 8D

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.