69
the final results of my quest to clone muffin man..
submitted over 9 years ago by spaceghost_n_moltar

back when muffin man first came out i bought into it just like a lot of you probably did. My first hit of that stuff made my eyes roll back in my head it was so good. although, half a tank in i got a dry hit, i went to inspect my build and it was caked in black char. less than 30mls of the stuff, i swore it off forever because it was packed with sucralose, destroyed coils and after seeing past the mirage of the sweetness and price of the juice, it was pretty two dimensional. so i started my quest to clone the stuff, but better yet make it more dynamic without adding any sweeteners. so here it is..

Ms.Cookies

  • FA Almond 0.2%
  • FA Apple pie 1%
  • TFA Apple pie 2.5%
  • TFA Caramel original 1%
  • FA Fuji 0.1%
  • TFA Oatmeal Cookie 4%
  • FA Pear 0.2%
  • CAP Sugar Cookie 1%
  • TFA Vanilla Custard 1%

http://e-liquid-recipes.com/recipe/500727/Ms.Cookies+

for those interested in the process

i never really got any muffin flavor from muffin man, just apple and cinnamon with a touch of brown sugar. after failing over and over to find a good muffin base i decided to switch gears and go apple cinnamon cookie. TFA's Oatmeal cookie fit perfectly, a rich cinnamon-y almost cakelike cookie. then to build up the apple pie note. TFA's apple pie was good, but i decided to bump it up a bit with FA apple pie as well. Ive tired both by themselves but i settled on a mix of the two. next was the bright apple flavor, you get on the inhale. FA fuji was my go to, but it was a little too familiar to me because it works its way into a lot of my recipes. I decided to accent it with some FA pear just to make it new and exciting. This became the first iteration of the mix witch honestly was pretty good, but after about 60ml i got bored of it and went back to the drawing board. the cookie needed more. on a whim i added some FA almond and some CAP sugar cookie to add some buttery-ness and to "harden" the cookie and make more like a hard cookie rather than a moist cakey cookie. some TFA vanilla custard added more mouthfeel and a touch of vanilla. after picturing what this would look like in real life the only part that was missing was caramel drizzled all over the top and since i was out of FA caramel at the time, i decieded to try one of the caramel flavors i dont use so often, TFA caramel original and bam. the juice muffin man wishes it was.

now here's the crazy part. its a shake n vape! well ok not the best or most simple shake n vape, but the important part is it is totally vapable after just a heat bath and it only gets better with age. after the first week the cookie gets more rich, the almond comes out more, the brightness of the fruits and apple pie settle a bit and the custard gets a bit more noticeable.

im really proud of this mix, it holds the same notes that Muffin man had but adds to them and goes the extra mile. Id love some feedback on this mix.

Comments
Sort
7 points
 
by probywan1337over 9 years agoI will rip you a new one if you don't use the sidebar & search.

I need to quit coming here. Always end up ordering stuff every time lol. Nice notes though. Definitely gonna try to get these flavorings in soon

2 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

yeah, i have over 100 flavors because of that. thanks!

7 points
 
by matthewkocandaover 9 years ago

I'm drunk as hell right now and reading this post inspired me to make a pretty large purchase on flavours. So in a few days, I will be able to mix this up. Very excited to try it. It sounds delicious.

3 points
 
by snakefinnover 9 years ago

When drunk online shopping goes.. right

-2 points
 
by danielfromparisover 9 years ago

lol

3 points
 
by Vurveover 9 years agoVurve with the Swurve

Alright, I'll be mixing this up in a few minutes. Totally pysched.

2 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

hope you dig it as much as i do.

2 points
 
by Vurveover 9 years agoVurve with the Swurve

I had to sub CAP Vanilla Custard, but holy crap this is good!

Once the Fuji mellows out, I think this will be really spot on.

1 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

Cap VC should bear basically the same result.

3 points
 
by The_Perrycoxover 9 years agoMentholatier

400 ish flavors and I don't have oatmeal cookie. It's always something!

Recipe looks amazing, def adding oatmeal cookie to my never ending list

2 points
 
by DoombotnAZover 9 years ago

This looks and sounds so good. I don't have all the flavors but I will soon enough. Whip some up and let you know.

2 points
 
by l_StarKiller_lover 9 years ago

Good job, will definitely be trying this.

PS- I completely agree with you on the muffin man, nothing but cinnamon and apple and entirely too much damn sweetener. Sickening really.

1 points
 
by Xexistover 9 years ago

I wont try this anytime soon, missing multiple flavours, but congrats on finding something you really like and thanks for sharing the recipe with us!

1 points
 
by workerbee41over 9 years ago

How does yours compare with /u/ENYAWREKLAW 's http://diyordievaping.com/2015/08/18/apple-butter-oatmeal-cookie/ ?

3 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

i have made his before and i like it. but the biggest difference here is going to be the TFA oatmeal cookie, it completely changes the cookie base from a buttery cookie to a dark brown sugar oatmeal cookie. also the amount of fuji is going to completely change the flavor, at 2.5% its one of the main notes at .25 in mine, its very subtle and just enhances the other fruits that are already there.

3 points
 
by Enyawreklawover 9 years agoCreator - Best Recipe of 2015: Rhodonite

I was actually supposed to create another version of my recipe with TFA oatmeal cookie but malaise set in. I can't wait to try yours though, shit looks good. I like that touch of Pear in there.

1 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

Thanks alot man, means a lot coming from you. leme know what you think!

1 points
 
by workerbee41over 9 years ago

Sounds great! And yeah, Fuji is so strong. I made up another recipe using it, and came away with the feeling that it was almost the same as ABOC even with far fewer flavor ingredients. I never got any kind of oatmeal hint from ABOC.

1 points
 
by cjinctover 9 years ago

> also the amount of fuji is going to completely change the flavor, at 2.5% its one of the main notes at .25 in mine

Your recipe has it at 0.10 - should it be 0.25?

sounds fabulous btw and I've got everything for it - so on the list it goes =)

1 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

Yes it's 0.1 my bad. Hope you dig it

1 points
 
by TIP-YOUR-UBER-DRIVERover 9 years ago

How much sucralose would you add , or do you think they have in the muffin man? How long would you think it takes to steep?

I've tried various amounts plus EM and am having no such luck with other recipes. ; (

1 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

im sure they have about 3-5% sucralose in their recipe. i personally dont like sucralose in my recipes, it gums up coils and just over sweetens it no matter what. imo this recipe is sweet enough, but if you have a sweet tooth, i would say add a bit of EM maybe .3% and bump up the caramel original another 1% and steep for about a week that should sweeten this up quite a bit.

1 points
 
by TIP-YOUR-UBER-DRIVERover 9 years ago

Are you sure about the 3-5% suctalose? Why not 3-5% EM? I have tried both and they seem to kill all my recipies, so I was almost wondering if they were using that "super sucralose" at maybe 1%.

I'm totally lost when it comes to EM vs Sucralose as it doesn't seem to enhance anything and just drowns out flavors, even the great recipies available here.

Perhaps I need to let it steep a lot longer?

1 points
 
by BooksofMagicover 9 years agoMixologist

You mentioned you would normally use FA Caramel - do you think it would work in this instead of the TPA caramel?

1 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

i think it would just sweeten it up and blend into all the other dark sugar flavors in the recipe. FA caramel to me is more of like a syrupy caramelized sugar flavor. caramel original seems to stand out on its own as a Werthers original, butterscotchy caramel drizzle kind of flavor. if sure it would work fine, but its just not going to be the same.

1 points
 
by crosstown_rebelover 9 years ago

this is probably nowhere near muffin man but probably a better recipe overall. im sure you left the sweetener out because, coils, but i swear it probably has at least 3% sucralose in there.

1 points
 
by Pixels_On_Fireover 9 years agoMixologist

Great job!

1 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

Thanks =)

1 points
 
by ryan770over 9 years ago

While I don't have the Apple pies, oatmeal, and caramel, you've inspired me to make a recipe, using either FA Biscuit or Cookie, and TFA Pie crust as some substitutes in conjunction with the other flavors to possibly create something good. May have to bump up the Fuji a little and the TFA Custard for some more spice.

1 points
 
by Burritoclockover 9 years ago

I love you. I wanted desperately to use oatmeal cookie in something. and pear. I haven't used either of those. I am excite.

1 points
 
by spaceghost_n_moltarover 9 years ago

Lol thanks man, I kinda did the same thing. I got oatmeal cookie cause it was just released at the time and it sat on my flavor rack for almost a month before I found a use for it or even tasted it. It's a pretty awesome flavor IMO. FA pear is very concentrated and the weird part is the "texture" of a pear comes through. In this recipe tho it just enhances the Apple note

1 points
 
by Burritoclockover 9 years ago

Sat down to make this and realized I had TPA Pear... made it anyway and I think that TPA pear is not cut out for this job lol.

1 points
 
by tobecohoover 9 years ago

Thanks so much for this gonna mix a bottle up right when i get home sub a flavor or two. More flavors in the cart..

1 points
 
by AvarriannaRoxxzorabout 9 years ago

well, this looks like it puts my two step recipe to shame.

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.