14
Fine tuning rootbeer recipes for a week, then I found a hidden little recipe in this sub!
submitted almost 10 years ago by ilikeycoffeeExtractor

So the last week or so, I've been going back and forth trying to fine tune a root beer recipe (most results were disastrous - not good luck with Lorann's sassafras), so I took to deep searching this sub and other sources for ideas or thoughts, and happened upon this post by /u/ReverendSaintJay. At the end of a great posting about trials and tribs of using a magnetic stirrer heater, was a little recipe:

  • TFA Root Beer - 8%
  • TFA Wintergreen - 2%
  • TFA Vanilla Bean Ice Cream - 2%

Well, I have all those so I mixed it up (and gave it a 30min stir at 50C). Pretty damned good! A bit dry / chalky on the exhale though (that's, IMO, the wintergreen components) but really good! So I fooled around with it a bit more. My memory of A&W Root Beer back in the day is super creamy and a nice vanilla flavour to go along with the sassafras/wintergreen. So I have TPA's Root Beer Float, and I had to make a choice - am I going for A&W Root Beer, or A&W Root Beer Float? I went the latter:

###A&W Root Beer Float ###

  • TPA Root Beer Float 7%
  • TPA Vanilla Bean Ice Cream 1.5%
  • FW Wintergreen (I like it better than TPA's) 1.5%
  • FA Madagascar Vanilla (Bourbon) (boosting VBIC's vanilla): .5%
  • Optional - to really "cream" this up, add 2% TPA DX Sweet Cream
  • 50/50 PG/VG

This requires a nice steep - I'd guess 2-4 days shaking every morning and evening; I also have a magnetic stirrer heater so I gave it a half hour, high rpm 50C spin.

Give it a go - and again, shoutout to the good Reverend!

Comments
Sort
2 points
 
by fritobandito32almost 10 years agoMixologist

Have you tried FW Root Beer Float by chance?

1 points
 
by ilikeycoffeealmost 10 years agoExtractor

I haven't - only TFA and Lorann. What's the FW like?

1 points
 
by fritobandito32almost 10 years agoMixologist

Haven't played with it much, but its pretty solid. Doesn't need any Wintergreen added but could use some cream!

2 points
 
by epresleyalmost 10 years ago

Will you please elaborate on your stirrer/heater? Where did you get it? Would you recommend investing in one?

2 points
 
by r0guez0mbiealmost 10 years agoMixologist

Just wanted to thank you again for this recipe. Vaping it now and it's lovely! As it turns out, growing up here (South Africa), we had a bubblegum simply named Wicks Bubblegum, no flavour name. And as it turns out, it was root beer flavour.... The company didn't market it as such, but as soon as I smelt it, it was instantly familiar.

1 points
 
by NotCharlesMansonalmost 10 years ago

>FA Sweet Cream

Typo?

I'm going to have to add these flavors to the list. It sounds really good. I'm sad it only took me one minute to read a post by you, though. I need more!

1 points
 
by ilikeycoffeealmost 10 years agoExtractor

Oops my bad, was thinking about the sweetest cream I have that could boost the recipe, and for some reason I always think TPA's Sweet Cream is made by FA :D

LOL! I promise a new wall of text, soon!

1 points
 
by NotCharlesMansonalmost 10 years ago

Good! I need my weekly knowledge fix.

1 points
 
by Fawgmachinealmost 10 years ago

I do as well. I think it's because it has FA potency lol.

1 points
 
by grrumble66almost 10 years ago

I can't find TFA Root Beer in stock anywhere so I'll order the missing ingredients and give this one a try. Thanks! :)

1 points
 
by r0guez0mbiealmost 10 years agoMixologist

We don't get Root Beer here. Am I correct in thinking it tastes like a "minty cola"... more or less?

1 points
 
by ilikeycoffeealmost 10 years agoExtractor

Root beer is its own beast. Doesn't really taste like coca cola (even a minted coca cola) at all to me. It's closest cousin is birch beer.

2 points
 
by r0guez0mbiealmost 10 years agoMixologist

Thank you. I'll have to order the TFA Root Beer then. Something completely new to me sounds intriguing.

2 points
 
by Namrorrimalmost 10 years ago

You are in for a treat, i love rootbeer!

2 points
 
by Rampant_Platypusalmost 10 years ago

Root beer tastes like Deep Heat smells, basically.

1 points
 
by waterhead99almost 10 years ago

I use a similar recipe, but use vanilla instead of the Madagascar vanilla. Been wondering about adding meringue to thicken it up with some creaminess.

1 points
 
by Namrorrimalmost 10 years ago

Shit man, I have every one of these flavors in the mail right now. They arrive in a few days, and this recipe looks BOMB!

Thanks, will get back to you with my results :D

1 points
 
by sthprk33almost 10 years ago

Great looking recipe, I'm going to give it a shot! Quick question (for anyone that can answer): I have both FA Vanilla Bourbon and FA Vanilla Classic (both ordered from eliquidmart.com). Which one is "Madagascar"? Your recipe indicates it would be the Bourbon, but looking at BCV, they have it listed as "Madagascar (Vanilla Classic)".
I'm totally confused.

1 points
 
by ilikeycoffeealmost 10 years agoExtractor

Madagascar Vanilla = Bourbon Vanilla. Bourbon is one of the islands (now called Reunion) in that region where vanilla is grown.

I wrote up a lengthy post on vanilla and its history and sourcing - if you have about 6 minutes (that's what Medium says it takes to read it lol), go give it a read.

0 points
 
by sureal808-almost 10 years ago

I ADV classic root beer by Gold Seal E-Liquids. It comes in a 50/50 30ml bottle which I add 70ml of VG to and the flavor is absolutely amazing!

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.