14
Why is it hard to find good cherry and punch flavors? Anyone have recipes for these?
submitted about 10 years ago by jrk190

Being a broke-ass college student sucks, so I figure I might as well get into DIY. I'm sick of having to drive far to buy overpriced juice that is sub-par, so I'd give it a go myself. I'm looking to make a good cherry or punch flavor, and hopefully buy most of the stuff I need locally. Any ideas?

Comments
Sort
2 points
 
by meanrockSDabout 10 years ago

There are only 3 good cherry flavors I've tried, FW Maraschino Cherry, FW Cherry Crush, and FA Cherry. Hangsen Cherry isn't bad, but its a distant fourth to those other 3.

4 points
 
by ThirdWorldOrderabout 10 years ago

FA Black Cherry as well.

I'd also look into FW Shirley Temple and/or TFA Champagne. TFA Swedish Fish can also help with cherry flavoring

1 points
 
by WaterFlourYeastabout 10 years agoMixologist

I use black cherry a lot more than regular cherry. I like the deep dark note it has, I use FA Cherry as more of a booster

1 points
 
by WaterFlourYeastabout 10 years agoMixologist

INW Cherries is pretty good, I use it in my cherry pie :)

2 points
 
by skiddlzninjaabout 10 years agoFrugivore

If you're looking to buy locally, you're about to be sorely disappointed.

1 points
 
by vapingrammyabout 10 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Have you tried cherry crush from FW? I haven't used mine yet but someone told me on this sub Reddit that it was a good cherry replacement.

1 points
 
by jrk190about 10 years ago

Hm, not yet... I prefer to buy things in stores, so that'd be a plus. I'd like to make a run this weekend or the next.

1 points
 
by vapingrammyabout 10 years agoOne of "The Damned"

Oh ok. There is no store around here that sells these type flavoring so.

1 points
 
by juice_junkieabout 10 years ago

I like marshino cherry FW and citrus punch tpa with a little bit of vanilla swirl tpa

1 points
 
by BuryMeInSmokeabout 10 years ago

I used TFA black cherry with a bit of TFA strawberry and TFA blueberry in a black forest cake recipe. Still tasted like cherry but lost that cough syrup flavour that cherry can get.

1 points
 
by sinnersaint9about 10 years ago

I had cherry blossom, and it was pretty good. Kind of like a black cherry flavor if used right. Can't remember who makes it. It was either cap or tfa

2 points
 
by bcvapecoabout 10 years ago

TFA

1 points
 
by cookfryabout 10 years ago

I absolutely love TFA's Hawaiian drink. On its own its a little overpowering. But with equal parts dragon fruit, blackberry, and black currant it makes an amazing tropical punch juice.

But yeah, you aren't going to find the ingredients for diy locally.

Best of luck!

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.