I like using spreadsheets to organize information. I was originally going to only do clone recipes i was interested in, but said ef-it, and did the whole list here (so thanks to /u/snowman5555 & /u/icecreamterror). Also, no reason to be stingy. So, here you go:
Use the menu button (to the left of the tabs on the bottom) to easily navigate the list.
I'm also working on a user submitted "original" recipe list. I'll share that when I'm done.
I gotta mention this, had anybody actually tried that black out city recipe? It's absolutly awful and not even close to the original. I get annoyed when I see it on these lists.
If it's really that bad we can certainly remove it. Or, we can replace it with a better mix if someone has one or is willing to take on that challenge.
That's the problem with quite a few of these recipes. I appreciate the time and effort that it took to put the list together but there are some really bad recipes in there. It's also the most up voted post in this sub's history. You can go back to the original post and there little or no discussion as to the quality of any of them. That's mostly due to the short lifespan of a reddit thread. Hopefully we can keep this one going with some reviews and revisions.
Does anyone else think 12% TFA butterscotch is way too much in the Claim Your Throne recipe? I actually tried that one and it didn't taste like butterscotch at all.
I actually found the brown sugar to be too overpowering and a coil destroyer. Then again I've never had the original so don't know how it's supposed to taste but I did end up binning that mix
Really dont think the brown sugar was the problem. I'm gonna mix it again at 2% butterscotch and drop the cream to around 3%. I'm thinking whoever posted the old thread made a serious typo or two on that one.
Awesome work. Just a suggestion, you might want to consider attributing the creators of each recipe, especially for the "original" recipes spreadsheet you're collating
Thank you.
The the initial "original" recipe list does give credit. Those were easier to track down.
This clones list might be a challenge. It's my understanding that the recipes come from several different sites, some (or maybe all) of which don't visit this subreddit.
However, I'm definitely not opposed to giving credit where it is due. I'm happy to amend this list as much as warranted to give credit. I'll certainly do so if I discover that information or I am made aware of it.
How would this work for campfire,
3% fa chocolate 6% cap marshmallow 3% cap graham cracker v2?
Can't hurt to try. Personally I'd lower the marshmallow to some extent. Maybe around 4.
I thought capella was around 1.5x strength of tfa? just trying to keep the ratios.