10
Marshmallow Milkshake would you change anything?
submitted over 10 years ago by sub_ohm_gnome

One of my local italian eateries makes a bomb a$$ marshmallow milkshake, and I asked them the ingredients, which is basically vanilla bean gelato, toasted marshmallows, and a little bit of milk. I figured I would try make a juice emulation of it. Wondering if you would add anything else, substitute anything, get rid of anything, or change percentages :

  • 3% Marshmallow (TFA)
  • 2% Toasted Marshmallow (TFA)
  • 4% Vanilla Bean Gelato (TFA)
  • 1% French Vanilla Creme (TFA)
  • 1% Malted Milk (TFA)
  • .5% Dairy Milk (TFA)
  • .5% Sweetner (TFA)
Comments
Sort
5 points
 
by tet5uoover 10 years ago

You most likely won't need the sweetener with all that marshmallow in there.

1 points
 
by sub_ohm_gnomeover 10 years ago

Yeah I was debating on the sweetner, I know the marshmallow sometimes doesnt come off that sweet, so I decided to try adding just a touch of sweetner, maybe Ill leave it out first attempt. Thanks for advice!

1 points
 
by P33Tover 10 years ago

I just stopped using sucralose (TFA Sweetener) in all my juices because it seems to gunk up my coils and cotton. I actually used TFA marshmallow in its place and it seems to have been a good choice so far!

1 points
 
by sub_ohm_gnomeover 10 years ago

Interesting! What percent ranges were you using in your recipes for the sweetner?

2 points
 
by jmillermcpover 10 years ago

Have you thought about TFA Vanilla Bean Ice Cream? I absolutely love this flavor and it may give your recipe a little more depth without altering your goal too much. Definitely dump the sweetener, it will be sweet enough.

1 points
 
by sub_ohm_gnomeover 10 years ago

That is two for dumping the sweetner, and yes I did think about the Vanilla Bean Ice Cream! I think another order.... is in order! Thanks for the advice! :)

1 points
 
by MommysSalamiover 10 years ago

I want one of the more experienced guys to come in and tell you if any of those would interact in a non desirable way, what you can tweak, etc. Looks like a juice I would like though! The milkshake sounds dank

1 points
 
by Butterd_Toostover 10 years ago

Agreed. This sounds pretty tasty although it's probably a coil killer lol maybe use as a base and add blackberry, cherry, raspberry or some other fruit on top?

1 points
 
by sub_ohm_gnomeover 10 years ago

Lol! What do you mean a coil killer, havent heard that one before! ;-)

3 points
 
by Butterd_Toostover 10 years ago

Juice with sweeteners get your coils wicked gunky lol

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.