21
Is there any way to achieve this color without dye?
submitted over 10 years ago by The_PerrycoxPâtissier

Howdy folks, quick question for ya'll. There is a company, called Clutch vapors. They have two blends that are VERY colorful, straight up bright red and pink. I was curious if it was at all possible that the color of this liquid, and T.K.O. can be achieved without food coloring/dye.

I only ask because when I questioned them on Instagram, and they said there was no dye in their liquid. Their answer was "it's from the flavoring, raspberry is red". I know for goddamn sure Moab has FA forest fruit And Fuji/Apple in it. Never seen my shit turn neon from those.

Thanks in advance!

{edit} I have apparently been blocked from their Instagram. Awesome! Inhale that dye..

Comments
Sort
5 points
 
by GVSCSover 10 years ago

Very bright or neon like colors are generally an indication of artificial/food coloring. Fruit flavorings that are clear generally mean there is no artificial coloring. Darker colors might be achieved without coloring, but probably not blindingly bright neon colors. If you have a juicer or blender at home you can observe this for yourself when making juice from real fruits and vegetables.

1 points
 
by The_Perrycoxover 10 years ago

Thanks for your input! Unless they're using a beet juice extract, I suspect dye. I've had liquid turn a variety of colors/shades. Nothing ever came from the Crayola factory though. This would probably aggravate me less if they were a bit more transparent about it.

1 points
 
by vansprinkelover 10 years ago

I've had juices go pretty orange on their own. Not bright fluorescent orange, but a nice deep orange that was very, orange in appearance. That was from using cream and blueberry, although I suspect it's the cream mostly that gives it the orange color. But yeah orange is pretty Crayolaesque.

1 points
 
by GVSCSover 10 years ago

Unfortunately, a lab analysis aside, we only know what they are willing to tell us.

5 points
 
by onmywaydownnowover 10 years ago

And they blocked you. Well get some proof and do a PSA. Assholes.

2 points
 
by prime1ndustriesover 10 years agoMixologist

I agree. We know some liquids have dye in them from using certain flavorings such as LA, so why be so shady as to block someone who is merely questioning? If there is dye in your product, admit it to your customers, or do something to prevent it. The company's actions here wreak of shadiness.

1 points
 
by onmywaydownnowover 10 years ago

I feel like the LA banana cream has dye in it. And I still love it. It doesn't mean people are going to stop using it. But yeah with money involved people get scared of losing their investment. I understand. This community is pretty reasonable though if you make an effort to change.

1 points
 
by prime1ndustriesover 10 years agoMixologist

Sure does... Yellow #5, as stated on the bottle. Funny, way back in high school kids always joked the Yellow #5 in Mountain Dew was going to make your um... "junk" shrink! I'm curious if this was just something that was said at my school only, or was this a widespread urban legend?

Disclosure: All this aside, I still use LA Banana Cream in some of my recipes. I don't drink Mountain Dew though hah.

4 points
 
by petetheredover 10 years ago

Flavor west has an Natural Raspberry - http://flavorwest.com/index.php/natural-flavoring/rapberry-natural.html

It's dark red in the bottle, and when added to juice gives it a reddish/pink tint.

A lot of the apple juices when mixed give things a yellowish tint ( I have a watermelon / apple blend that took on neon-yellow tint after steeping in bottle for a week or so ) , so maybe with the raspberry natural it will take that red color.

My problem with the Raspberry natural is that it does NOT vape well ... i've tried it in place of raspberry / raspberry sweet from TFA and the flavor "cooks" badly when vaped... anything more than 1% ( 0.1ml in a 10ml ) of it and the juice is pretty much trash.

3 points
 
by petetheredover 10 years ago

I wanted to reiterate how bad it cooks.

It's fucking awful even at 3%.... it's this nasty earthy burnt flavor , and this was at 10 watts on a Subtank... not even that hot.

1 points
 
by The_Perrycoxover 10 years ago

Thanks man! I hadn't tried or seen that particular raspberry. I'm fairly certain that M.O.A.B is just FA Forest fruit and FA Fuji and Apple. Last time I mixed those, it was an opaque greenish brown.

1 points
 
by RobocopSuperfanover 10 years ago

Kind of off topic but I have both of those flavours coming in with my order tomorrow, if I wanted to try a MOAB type juice what percentages would you recommend? Start with a 3 and 3?

1 points
 
by The_Perrycoxover 10 years ago

Try 3% forest fruit

2% Fuji

1% Apple

I like to use .5% TFA pear to make the apple pop a bit more

3 points
 
by SDVAPEover 10 years ago

Imgur Here is a mix I made I call it Berry cupcake.....Tasty and this nice color

Blueberry Extra(TFA) 4% Raspberry(FW) 4% Strawberry(ripe)(TFA) 3% Vanilla Cupcake(TFA) 4% Whipped Cream(TFA) 2%

The raspberry from Flavor West is a deep deep dark color

By the way this mix is delicious

mixed at 3mg nic 20pg/80vg 30ML

2 points
 
by fizzmustardover 10 years agoBest Recipe of 2014

lulz

Is the actual juice that color or just in the product shots? High nic levels can tint the juice, but I've never seen to that extent.

1 points
 
by The_Perrycoxover 10 years ago

The liquid is actually that color! No fancy photoshop done.

1 points
 
by fizzmustardover 10 years agoBest Recipe of 2014

Lol, yeah, they're either dyeing it or using LorAnn flavors that are already dyed.

1 points
 
by omgitsvenomover 10 years ago

Looks like LorAnn Strawberry to me, by the looks of the color and the product description.

2 points
 
by Sandman0over 10 years ago

That's dye.

It might be "from the flavoring", but it's dye that was added to the flavoring by the manufacturer if that's the case.

LorAnn is bad about it, they put dye in everydamnthing.

A tint is one thing, I've seen flavors impart a super light purplish or bluish hue to liquid, but the liquid still appears clear, it's not neon purple or blue.

I've tried hundreds of flavorings, and I've never seen a single one that had color like that which wasn't dye.

Red is iffy depending on if the juice is aged. I've had juice start out clear or light yellow and turn red after aging. Not neon red, but pretty darn red.

For the most part if it's not clear, yellow, orange, red, or brown it's dye. Unfortunate, but that's the way it is. Even if it is those colors it still might be dye.

1 points
 
by maccabeusover 10 years agoPâtissier

this is not a color that occurs in nature. for that radioactive glow you need dye.

The only juice I've ever had that was this color is watermelon from Apollo, and it ruins wicks faster than chocolate.

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoFilling Orders!

I'd guess they are using LorAnn's raspberry, strawberry or watermelon of which there are colorless replacements for the raspberry and watermelon but not the strawberry. However, it is possible they are using a different raspberry/strawberry that also imparts artificial color. FWIW, the flavor does not inherently contain color, it's added by LorAnn's as the majority of their clients use it in food (primarly confection making) so it adds something for most of their clients.

http://www.onestopdiyshop.com/lorann-super-strength-colorless/

I still have an old vial of LA Raspberry from WizardLabs from way back in the day.

> Contents: Artificial Flavors, Propylene Glycol, Water, FD&C Red 40, FD&C Blue 1

I won't say this vendor was purposely misleading it's clients, based on your description of what they said, I'd assume instead that they are just completely clueless like many vendors out there, just there to make a quick buck with no real understanding of what the fuck they are doing.

1 points
 
by catdumplingover 10 years ago

I'm inclined to think there's food coloring in it (either from Clutch or the flavor mfg.) I've tried at least a dozen raspberry juices from various companies (none were that great, FWIW) and none of them were red; they were all clear or the standard pale straw color. If Clutch isn't adding the coloring themselves, whichever brand of flavoring they're using should state the food coloring type/number on the bottle of flavor concentrate (ie "Red #5" or whatever.)

On a side note: are there any good raspberry flavorings that don't taste like cough syrup or old lady perfume? It seems to be something of a unicorn from what I can tell.

1 points
 
by meanrockSDover 10 years ago

All of their lines use LorAnn andFlavor Art- I have not been able to track down whether they use TFA, Capella or other. They for DAMN sure use Dye in Many of their lines. Buckshot is their oldest and they just recently removed dye from those recipes. Joker from Time Bomb and Flare from RoyBot also have the same bright red hue as TKO. Looks like flavor that has the dye hasn't been sourced as colorless.

1 points
 
by caffeinedover 10 years ago

When I was playing with diy extracts, I had a tea flavor that color from just a couple drops of hibiscus extracted and concentrated in water. Quite a pleasant flavor with fruits. I imagine red grape skin extract would to the same, but it's harder to get a hold of.

1 points
 
by EternalNoobover 10 years ago

First of all I love TKO and I want to clone it really bad. I recently ordered some raspberry from Natures Flavors and it is super dark red. Tastes terrible too but I chock that up to not knowing what I'm doing. I imagine that if I used a lower percentage than I did initially the color would be spot on. My first mix was terrible.

0 points
 
by 00ssnorcalover 10 years ago

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q0dhvWA5iq4

1 points
 
by youtubefactsbotover 10 years ago

>How to Make Natural Food Coloring - Concentrated Color Recipe [4:40]

> ^Dulce ^Delight ^in ^Howto ^& ^Style

>^173,569 ^views ^since ^Jan ^2014

^bot ^info

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.