69
Best Recipe of 2014? (Contest)
submitted over 10 years ago by kirktBring on the Diacetyl, baby

I'm taking over the stickied post for a week or so to run a contest for "Best Recipe of 2014". This is not the place to nominate your own creation, but rather the best recipe that you found on this site last year made by another user. Do you have an ADV that you are crazy about? Here's the place to post it. PLEASE FOLLOW THE SUBMISSION FORMAT to make it easier for others to follow!

Format:

"Recipe name" by /u/username

<Flavor> (<Vendor>) @ x%
<Flavor> (<Vendor>) @ x%
<Flavor> (<Vendor>) @ x%

Your description of why you love this recipe should come next

Next should come any alterations / substitutions you made to the recipe

Winner gets... a big internet hug from the rest of us. Also maybe we can do a special flair to indicate the winner. Contest mode is enabled; top level posts not meeting submission rules will be deleted.

Oh and if you're looking for the January recipe thread, it can be found here or in the sidebar.

Comments
Sort
1 points
 
by kirktover 10 years agoBring on the Diacetyl, baby

"Key Lime Pie meant for drippers" by /u/Botboy141

Mixed 91.8% VG
Custard (FA) @ 1.7%
Key Lime (TFA) @ 3%
Pie Crust (TFA) @ 1%
Cheesecake Graham Crust (TFA) @ 2%
Lime Cold-Pressed (Tahiti not distilled) (FA) @ 0.5%

Why I nominated: This is one of those "perfection" recipes that for me captures every element I love about the original. Lime, custard, graham, (you can even taste the condensed milk) - all there and all in the perfect ratio. I've been vaping 50 mls of this every 7-10 days and I absolutely love it.

Changes I made:
I use CAP Vanilla Custard V2 in place of the FA, at the same %
Omitted the FA lime.

*Edited (twice) to follow my own format suggestions.

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

Probably one of my favorites of the year as well to be honest. At least of the ones I've posted. This and my Apple Pie were probably my favorite two discoveries of 2014.

1 points
 
by kirktover 10 years agoBring on the Diacetyl, baby

Wanna point me to the Apple Pie?

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

It's not posted and is my most popular seller.

1 points
 
by Colts1984over 10 years ago

http://www.gggejuice.com/mobile/Product.aspx?ProductCode=3300

In case you weren't familiar

1 points
 
by HexCoilsover 10 years ago

Comments like these make me wish I could just take a quick peek in your notebook, and then steal it.

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

muahaha ;-)

1 points
 
by LurkTr0nover 10 years ago

I've never tried FA custard so I'm curious as to why you used it rather than the more popular Cappella custard? Does it compliment this recipe better?

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

It has a hint of lemon to it and is more of a true Italian custard vs CAP's which is more of a US Vanilla pudding type flavor IMO.

I've used both in this recipe and the recipe was more popular among.my testing crowd with FA's.

It's also a stronger flavor, less percentage needed, and when this juice was originally under development, the plan was to offer it in a drip only max VG line. More VG the better =)

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

You totally failed the formatting edit.

1 points
 
by kirktover 10 years agoBring on the Diacetyl, baby

Any better now?

Some people are tough to please....

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

hehe ;-)

1 points
 
by izzytootsover 10 years ago

I'm going to have to try this now. I tried to make my own key lime pie recipe last night with much higher percentages and it is pretty damn good for one of my first ejuice mixes.

2% CAP graham cracker v2

8% TFA key lime

4.5% CAP vanilla custard v2

1.5% TFA coconut extra

Mixed with only vg at 2mg/ml nic with a couple drops distilled water

1 points
 
by simletover 10 years ago

I just wanted to reply and let you guys know I mixed this up and holy shit... its seriously delish as fuck. Shocked the amount of flavor it has with the low percentage that's actually in it. mixed up a 30ml to just try it, looks like maybe a 120ml is in my future.

1 points
 
by kirktover 10 years agoBring on the Diacetyl, baby

I'll admit it - one of the main reasons I started this thread was to give this recipe more attention. It's just too damn good to not get the acclaim it deserves.

Now having recently tasted Gunner's Gold Awesome Apple Pie, I think botboy is a real master mixer, way out of my league.

1 points
 
by simletover 10 years ago

I agree, I only tried Ghostly Grapple and next Friday I plan to get his 5-pack sampler, shit is tasty..and ofc we owe to OURSELVES to try his juice :P

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

Be cautious going to 120ml. The lime does NOT hold up over after about two weeks. Still working on this and hence why it's still 'under development' on my site.

1 points
 
by simletover 10 years ago

Thank you very much sir, suppose I will mix 30ml at a time.. wonder if some CA will help the lime stick around for a lil longer...

1 points
 
by Playcate25over 10 years ago

i ordered the supplies for this, i'm trying it.

Edit: I made this last night, it's awesome. NIce job /u/Botboy141.

On a side note, I received a jar of Raspberry Key Lime Jam for Xmas(really good). I may try to ad 1% raspberry to see if that adds another layer of goodness.

1 points
 
by BuryMeInSmokeover 10 years ago

If clones count...

/u/fizzmustard 'nana Cream clone

5.0% LA Banana Cream
3.0% TFA Dragon Fruit
7.0% TFA Strawberry
1 drop per mL Citric Acid

Mix at 30pg / 70vg

"The citric acid is an additive on top of the other ingredients. Mix up the flavorings, VG, PG and nic, then add your citric acid on top."    

"1.66g (0.25 tsp) of citric acid in 10mL of PG"
1 points
 
by raskolnikov206over 10 years agoPâtissier

I love this one because it never gets old and its in constant rotation. I enjoy it both with and without citric acid. Thanks /u/fizzmustard. I'd recommended using colorless LA Banana Cream

1 points
 
by aaa12585over 10 years ago

Where can we purchase the colorless version?

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

A group buy directly from Lorann. I think Lorann will only sell it colorless if it's bought in 5 gallons increments.

1 points
 
by JRuck504over 10 years ago

where do i order?!

1 points
 
by AsmallDinosaurover 10 years ago

From the bombies website

1 points
 
by clancy6969over 10 years ago

Finding this recipe convinced me to get into DIY, looking around for the gear now.

1 points
 
by Glitchlolover 10 years ago

"Tounge Fuck" revision by /u/tet5uo, inspired by /u/i_seen

7% Fruit Circles (TFA)
3% Fresh Cream (FA)
2.5% Berry Crunch (TFA)
2% Bavarian Cream (TFA)
2% Marshmallow (TFA)
1.5% Sweet Cream (TFA)

I really wanted to get onto the Cereal Killa bandwagon, but I couldn't find any in stock. Mixed this up and was blown away on the first pull after a shake. SO CREAMY. SO TASTY. It tastes more like the milk left over at the bottom of the fruitloops bowl than the cereal.

A few weeks later when my CK finally arrived, I loaded it up and it wasn't as good as my firstr tounge fuck experience. I was pretty dissapointed, especially because I'd bought 3 bottles of the stuff thinking it'd be amazing.

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

Have you compared it to the Cereal Killa Clone? I have both the original Cereal Killa and the clone. In my opinion the clone is significantly better than the original. It's my adv atm and I'm curious how this one stacks up.

1 points
 
by Glitchlolover 10 years ago

I think I'm still missing the tangerine and yellow cake. When those are back in stock at ECX or RTS, I'll throw an order in.

1 points
 
by ThirdWorldOrderover 10 years ago

Can you post the clone you are referring to?

1 points
 
by itekkover 10 years ago

Probably this one

http://www.reddit.com/r/cerealkillaclone/

1 points
 
by Elturielover 10 years ago

If by chance you still have this question, the cereal killa clone is significantly better than this in my opinion.

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

Thank you. Still haven't tried this one.

1 points
 
by simletover 10 years ago

I have the cereal flavors waiting in my mailbox, and I have the rest of these flavors on-hand... I do not see that you added any Lemon, which I understand was the secret to getting that signature CK taste? I am going to try 2 batches tonight, your recipe - and this one:

  • Fruit circles - 8%
  • Berry crunch - 5%
  • Lemon meringue Pie 3%
1 points
 
by Steegzqtover 10 years ago

Can vouch this simple one tastes great!

1 points
 
by eim1213over 10 years agoFrugivore

Plus one from me too. This is an amazing recipe, and so simple! ALL of my friends have been buying this from me like it was their job.

1 points
 
by JRuck504over 10 years ago

where can i order this?

1 points
 
by harleynoreenover 10 years ago

I lack "Fresh Cream (FA)" but this flavor is absolutely amazing. I think I may add a little bit of 'sharp' sweet. Great recipe! Much thanks!

1 points
 
by P33Tover 10 years ago

Just mixed this up sans the FA Fresh Cream because I don't have it. I'm sure that it rounds it out and makes it more like your milk after the cereal. But without it, this recipe is pretty excellent right away. Going to let it sit now and see how it turns out in a week or so :)

1 points
 
by Glitchlolover 10 years ago

Did the same thing and used whipped cream in its place. A really good shake and vape with that replacement. That was an ADV for me for a couple of weeks until the fresh cream came in and I mixed up a new batch, then head exploded at how good it became with fresh cream. Definitely makes this juice spectacular.

1 points
 
by P33Tover 10 years ago

When i first bought fruit circles I actually tried something really similar to this but without the berry crunch. It was definitely a difference maker. Can't wait to get my hands on fa fresh cream now.

1 points
 
by tet5uoover 10 years ago

I actually hate you now, for making me know what it's like to have reddit gold. I think I need to pay for a sub, now haha.

1 points
 
by HexCoilsover 10 years ago

How is this after steeping?

1 points
 
by MUll3T_x_MANiAKabout 10 years ago

Going to order these and mix some up. Can't wait to try it!

1 points
 
by scoopylooover 10 years ago

This one, which was invented by /u/iconoclastmunky

Peanut Butter Cup (all tfa flavors)

8% Peanut Butter

8% Double Chocolate Clear

4% Graham Cracker

2% Marshmallow

1% Lemon juice

Here's the thread where I talked about it a few months ago. It's really fantastic. And after a few weeks, it gets even richer and more flavorful. I always have a few 30 ml bottles of it aging and waiting. https://www.reddit.com/r/DIY_eJuice/comments/1yei3m/peanut_butter_cup_thank_you_for_this_recipe/

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

This is truly a fantastic recipe (one of the few chocolates I've vaped that I can stand), was this posted this year though or was it late 2013?

Edit: Not that it really matters :-)

1 points
 
by scoopylooover 10 years ago

I don't remember when it was first posted.

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

Me neither, I think I dug it out of the TFA Recipe thread sometime in June/July and mixed it for the first time then.

1 points
 
by JohnLaCuentaover 10 years ago

Lemon juice doe? Do you filter it before using? I wonder if citric acid can be used instead.

1 points
 
by Botboy141over 10 years agoAlmost caught up on orders...

You can use CA instead.

1 points
 
by f4t3xover 10 years ago

Just tried to make this, didn't have lemon juice so I put 2 drops of TFA Sour(malic acid) in a 30ml. HUGE MISTAKE, I guess that stuff is strong, I just get a extremely muted chocolate masked by a chemically sour flavor, remaking without the sour right now until I can get some lemon juice.

1 points
 
by scoopylooover 10 years ago

Awww... well maybe give it a few days to settle in?

1 points
 
by zigarettenpauseover 10 years ago

I'd love to try that recipe, though i only have DC Dark instead of Clear. How should i adapt the percentages so that i could use DC Dark? Never used the clear stuff, but 8% dark seems a lot to me..

1 points
 
by scoopylooover 10 years ago

I've never used dark, so I can't say, sorry..

1 points
 
by elmfuzzyover 10 years ago

I put in 1.5% lemon instead on 1% because I bumped the rest of the flavors up buy ~2%. Huge mistake, all I can taste is lemon now.

1 points
 
by scoopylooover 10 years ago

yikes! Maybe it'll settle in. ?

1 points
 
by henrywinklersayehhhover 10 years ago

I have TFA lemon, but I notice this says "lemon juice" where do you get the juice from... A lemon?

1 points
 
by scoopylooover 10 years ago

I just use bottled lemon juice.

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

"Cereal Killa Clone" by /u/jackster1232002

2% Hazelnut (FW)
2% Meringue (FA)
1.5% Bergamot (FA)
1% Orange (FA)
1% Sweet Tangerine (CAP)
3% Lemon (FE)
2% Yellow Cake (FW)

This has become an ADV for me. Ever since I had my first cereal vape (Oculus by Northern Lights) I've been crazy about them. That juice was actually what got me started on DIY. This one blows Oculus out of the park

1 points
 
by JRuck504over 10 years ago

where to order ?????

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

Order... the flavors? Or the juice itself?

1 points
 
by JRuck504over 10 years ago

the juice itself

1 points
 
by grrumble66over 10 years ago

I have been trying to get all of the ingredients to try this for a couple of months, Meringue and Bergamot being the problem ingredients. Finally got them ordered this week. I keep telling myself that those two ingredients constantly being out of stock means I will love this when I finally get to try it. :P

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

You have to try multiple vendors to get everything. It's obnoxious. The only thing that held me up was the FE Lemon. When that came in stock I bought a decent bit. I ordered enough the other night of everything to make a quart of juice. That'll be happening this weekend haha.

1 points
 
by grrumble66over 10 years ago

Finally got the last flavors I had been needing to mix this yesterday and mixed a 10ml 'tester' last night. I now know I'm going to need a much larger amount if it is going to have any chance of 'steeping.'

Instead of ordering the FE Lemon (vape budget last month sucked) I used a combination of TPA Lemon at 1% and CAP Lemon Sicily at 2% per jackster's reccomendation. I might have to try the FE Lemon now. :P

1 points
 
by oipunk99over 10 years ago

yuuuup.. this recipe is a pain in the ass to get together :(

1 points
 
by grrumble66over 10 years ago

But, as I know now, so worth the trouble. :)

1 points
 
by KoopaTroopazover 10 years ago

what brand is the lemon? FE?

1 points
 
by grrumble66over 10 years ago

http://www.ecigexpress.com/diy-e-liquid/diy-e-liquid-flavors/flavorsexpress/fruitexpress/lemon-by-flavors-express.html

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

Flavor Express, it's an ecigexpress brand. Here is a link to it.

1 points
 
by captaincannibalover 10 years ago

This is really high on the list for me. I don't vape it a ton anymore but it helped me realize a lot of helpful things about DIY in general as well as those specific ingredients - I now utilize Meringue, Hazelnut, and Yellow Cake in ways/recipes that I wouldn't have ever thought of before.

Plus its just really damn tasty.

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

I do periodically. I have a bunch of buddies who I make it for all the time. I've definitely learned a decent amount from it as well. It's a good juice.

1 points
 
by Playcate25over 10 years ago

made this last night(4 friggin vendors to get all the supplies), pretty damn good. Can't wait to see what steeping does to it.

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

Yep it is a hassle. I made myself a quart of it the other night so I don't have to worry about it for a good long time. It's okay fresh but it definitely develops a better flavor after a few days.

1 points
 
by Zaylinover 10 years ago

This is super duper late, but how apparent is the lemon in this? I don't know if you've tried VapeWild's FruitHoops, but it's what got me interested in trying out CK, but the lemon being a little too strong puts it just out of perfection for me.

I almost want to get into DIY soley so I can give this a shot, but if the lemon is a big note, I might try some different flavors.

1 points
 
by AF_Noctavisover 10 years ago

It's a key flavor for sure. It blends pretty well with the others though. I'll throw it back on the dripper tomorrow when I'm sober and see how it is with the focus on the lemon for you. I'd do it now but a drunk me isn't a good tester of flavors lol.

1 points
 
by Zaylinover 10 years ago

Thank's man, I'd appreciate that! I don't mind if it's there, as long as it's not overpowering the other flavors.

1 points
 
by grrumble66over 10 years ago

Personally, I think the lemon and orange are pretty balanced, but I used the 'alternate' lemon...

and that's the great thing about DIY. One flavor too strong? Just dial it back a little bit.

1 points
 
by Zaylinover 10 years ago

Thanks for the help! I'm definitely thinking of just buying the starter kit from Nude Nicotine, only thing holding me back is the price on the recomended kitchen scale, I see pocket scales on amazon for like $10 and unless I'm mistaken they're the same in terms of accuracy.

1 points
 
by cencsorover 10 years ago

I'd like to nominate Zoochberry Cream by et3rn1ty

3% Bavarian Cream (TPA)
0.2% Coconut Extra (TPA)
0.5% Dragon Fruit (TPA)
1% Marshmallow (TPA)
0.2% Orange Cream (TPA)
0.2% Pear (FA)
3% Strawberries and Cream (TPA)
1% Sweet Cream (TPA)
6% Sweet Strawberry (CAP)
7% Vanilla Custard (CAP)
2% Vanilla Swirl (TPA)
1% Whipped Cream (TPA)

http://e-liquid-recipes.com/recipe/31677/Zoochberry+Cream

One of the nicest recipes I've tried - really enjoying it, has been an ADV for me for a while and I've just gone and placed a big order specifically to make more of it!

1 points
 
by JRuck504over 10 years ago

where do i order?????

1 points
 
by daathover 10 years agoMixologist

He meant order flavors for it - but if you would like to try it, without ordering the flavors, you can go to the recipe then click the blue wrench, then click "Order this on VapeCrafter" :)

1 points
 
by JRuck504over 10 years ago

what would I need to do to make it 3mg nic and 80vg?

THANKS by the way!!!

1 points
 
by daathover 10 years agoMixologist

That recipe is private - Here is et3rn1ty's original :)

1 points
 
by z0yover 10 years ago

"Oreo's Vanilla Custard" by /u/UltimateOreo

>Vanilla Custard (CAP) - 12%

>French Vanilla (CAP) - 5%

>Bavarian Cream (TFA) - 0.6%

>Sweet Cream (TFA) - 0.4%

>Malted Milk (TFA) - 0.4%

>Graham Cracker (TFA) - 0.2%

>Holy Vanilla (DIY Flavor Shack) - 0.2%

>Yellow Cake (FW) - 0.2%

>Cinnamon Sugar Cookie (TFA) - 2 drops per 30ml from 20 gauge syringe

>Orange Cream (TFA) - 1 drop per 30ml from 20 gauge syringe

>New York Cheesecake (CAP) - 1 drop per 30ml from 20 gauge syringe

I absolutely love this mix. I haven't tried a lot of custards, including gremlin's which he was trying to clone, but this is perfect for me. The only problem is I vape so much of it that it really starts to lose some flavor after a few days. But if I could take only one recipe from 2014 it would be this.

I didn't make any changes, but I don't like dealing with drops and small percentages so I make a base with all the flavors under 1%. I think it's right, the calculations made sense to me at the time, but hard to get it exact with the drops in the original recipe.

Base: > PG - 35%

>Bavarian Cream (TFA) - 18%

>Sweet Cream (TFA) - 12%

>Malted Milk (TFA) - 12%

>Graham Cracker (TFA) - 6%

>Holy Vanilla (DIY Flavor Shack) - 6%

>Yellow Cake (FW) - 6%

>Cinnamon Sugar Cookie (TFA) - 2.5%

>Orange Cream (TFA) - 1.25%

>New York Cheesecake (CAP) - 1.25%

Then the recipe becomes:

>Vanilla Custard (CAP) - 12%

>French Vanilla (CAP) - 5%

>Base - 3.33%

1 points
 
by UltimateOreoover 10 years agoMixologist

Thanks for the nomination! This would be a good time to post my updated recipe!

I've added a flavor, but decreased flavoring overall.

There should be less flavor fatigue, and the juice should taste 'sharper', or more defined if that makes sense.

Plus, the new flavor MAKES this juice.


Based on a 30 mL recipe

14% Flavoring


Vanilla Custard (CAP) - 3mL

French Vanilla (CAP) - .75mL

Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (TFA) - .15mL

Bavarian Cream (TFA) - .05mL

Sweet Cream (TFA) - .05mL

Malted Milk (TFA) - .05mL

Graham Cracker (TFA) - .03mL

Holy Vanilla (DIY Flavor Shack) - .03mL

Yellow Cake (FW) - .03 mL

Cinnamon Sugar Cookie (TFA) - 2 drops / 30mL

Orange Cream (TFA) - 1 drop / 30mL

New York Cheesecake (CAP) - 1 drop / 30 mL


Enjoy! I like it MUCH better this way.

1 points
 
by z0yover 10 years ago

Awesome, thanks for the update. I've got 8oz of VC on the way and I can't wait to try this out.

1 points
 
by raskolnikov206over 10 years agoPâtissier

Hello friend. Have you used FA condensed milk in combination with capellas custard?

1 points
 
by Czarcasm-over 10 years ago

What calculator can I use to get the percentages?

1 points
 
by billgarmsarmyover 10 years agoFrugivore

doing the math gave me this:

  • Van C (CAP) 10%

  • French Van (CAP) 2.5%

  • Van Bean IC (TFA) .5%

  • Bav C (TFA) .167%

  • Sweet C (TFA) .167%

  • Malted Milk (TFA) .166%

  • Graham Cracker (TFA) .1%

  • Holy Vanilla (DIYFS) .1%

  • Yellow Cake (FW) .1%

  • total 13.8%

Drops the rest, 20ga syringe iirc

i imgainge the other .2% comes from the drops

1 points
 
by martyhinesover 10 years ago

"French Toast" by /u/vapor_trails_nw

  • Waffle (TFA) @ 10%
  • Vanilla Swirl (TFA) @ 4%
  • Cinnamon Danish Swirl (Capella) @ 4%

This is an amazing recipe. It tastes really good right away, so you'll want to make a couple bottles, because when it has steeped it is pure gold. The maple note combine perfectly with the VS and CDS giving a whole that is greater than the sum of it's parts.

I also nominated this recipe because I think Matt deserves some props for his contributions to this sub. I speak personally when I say his TFA recommendations thread was a huge boon to my foray into DIY. Then, when he discontinues a couple of juices from his line due to diacetyl/AP, he gives us the recipes.

1 points
 
by stateekover 10 years ago

This sounds interesting. I don't have TFA Waffle but I do have Capella - have you tried with Cap instead of TFA? What about a different type of vanilla?

1 points
 
by martyhinesover 10 years ago

> have you tried with Cap instead of TFA?

I haven't tried it with Cap's waffle, as I don't own it.

Mix up a small batch. I can't imagine that it'll be unvapable. If you still don't like it after a few weeks, you can toss it. That's why you start with a small batch.

> What about a different type of vanilla?

Go for it! That's what makes DIY awesome. You may find that you've created something that you like better than the original recipe.

At some point, you should get these exact flavors and mix this up. It's amazing.

1 points
 
by Sens420over 10 years agoMentholatier

"Channer/Cholar Bear" by /u/project_twenty5oh1

6.0% TFA DK Base

5.0% TFA Banana Cream

3.0% TFA Banana Nut Bread

1.0% TFA Bananas Foster

3.0% TFA Peanut Butter

0.3% TFA Koolada  

0.2% TFA Coconut Extra

0.3% TFA Smooth

1.0% Strong Mint/Menthol Concentrate

This juice has seriously ruined vaping for me. I have a fairly extensive collection of juice, and I used to swap throughout the day. No longer. This is my all day-- everyday morning to night vape and has been for months. I tried to go back to my other juices, nope. I have all this DIY stuff that I got over the holidays collecting dust, haven't touched it, don't need it. This stuff is that good.

Anyways :) huge shouts to /u/project_twenty5oh1 for the time and effort put into this masterpiece and sharing it with the world (if you don't have the means to make this yourself, drop him a PM and I'm sure you can work around getting some sent to you)

Cheers!

1 points
 
by kirktover 10 years agoBring on the Diacetyl, baby

What is DK Base? Is there anything I can sub for it, because I have everything else in your list.

1 points
 
by Sens420over 10 years agoMentholatier

Tobacco, which flavors vary quite a bit. Not sure if it would be noticeable if you swapped it for something else. The tobacco flavor doesn't come out in the final flavor of the juice, but adds an earthy tone IMO.

1 points
 
by kirktover 10 years agoBring on the Diacetyl, baby

OK. I don't really vape tobacco but I have FA liquid amber which kind of does the same thing. Thanks for your submission / writeup / response.

1 points
 
by project_twenty5oh1over 10 years agoMixologist

Aw shucks, thank you for the kind words. So glad you're enjoying it :)

1 points
 
by Sens420over 10 years agoMentholatier

NP, just make sure you send that order out this week :)

1 points
 
by project_twenty5oh1over 10 years agoMixologist

You know I will!

1 points
 
by billgarmsarmyover 10 years agoFrugivore

> This juice has seriously ruined vaping for me. I have a fairly extensive collection of juice, and I used to swap throughout the day. No longer. This is my all day-- everyday morning to night vape

this. exactly this. i haven't even looked at my other supplies. i just wish i could buy icicles concentrate instead of the mixed juice.

1 points
 
by Sens420over 10 years agoMentholatier

Cant be that hard to mimic the icicles effect? Its probably 10-20% menthol crystals with a little koolada? I've never had it on its own. Is it mint or menthol?

1 points
 
by billgarmsarmyover 10 years agoFrugivore

i can't answer that question

it's not a huge deal. i just get icicles in 0mg nic from axiom and use it at 5% in the recipe in place of the 1% "strong mint or menthol" because icicles is 20% flavor so 5% of the juice gets me 1% of icicles.

1 points
 
by benisanerdabout 10 years ago

The dude came into my shop, I think he said it's 3 kinds of mints. Like wintergreen, spearmint, and menthol probably. I tried it in his kayfun and it just tasted like liquid nitrogen to me.

1 points
 
by PinheadXover 10 years ago

/u/project_twenty5oh1 told me that his original posted recipe was incorrect. He told me that the TFA Banana Cream is supposed to be 4%

adjust PG (or VG, but I'd use PG for the ratio to be the same) to compensate

1 points
 
by Sens420over 10 years agoMentholatier

No kidding...you'd think he'd edit his original post! Thanks for the heads up. I haven't actually tried my hand at this recipe yet, I get it right from the source.

1 points
 
by PinheadXover 10 years ago

I'd like to try some of his, since I don't have the stir plate he uses, but I mixed some up and set it on my stove (the pilot lights on the gas stove keep it a nice warm temp without actually heating it past what would be safe) and shook it every few hours, and it turned out really damn good.

I love Nanner Bear, and I'll probably continue to buy it on occasion, but I can't afford to buy as much as I need (ADV) so this hits the spot for me on the daily.

1 points
 
by Sens420over 10 years agoMentholatier

I also think that I might try a "dank-ier" tobacco in this mix to give it a more musty/earthy taste. I love the way that the tobacco comes through in this but my taste could use a little more.

1 points
 
by PinheadXover 10 years ago

I just read (and replied) to someone who mixed TFA RY4 and RY4 Extra together at 5% each and it apparently takes the perfuminess out of the RY4 and the caramel out of the RY4 extra and leaves a very "cigarette tobacco" flavor that doesn't need a long steep time (4 days or so). Maybe adding that in might be an interesting variation.

Post here: http://www.reddit.com/r/DIY_eJuice/comments/2tsmic/best_tobacco_flavorsrecipes_looking_for_sweet_or/co21n78

Site copyright © 2025 DIY Compendium. Data courtesy of Reddit.